3 ms·
This is such an HN comment to take a statement that's broadly true and a good one-liner that's understandable for most people, point out an exception, and concl
by Spivak 5y ago
This is such an HN comment to take a statement that's broadly true and a good one-liner that's understandable for most people, point out an exception, and conclude that the whole thing is false, pointless and they should have phrased it super precisely to account for edge cases that people with any amount of common sense get immediately.
* If you were underweight when you were 21 you probably shouldn't strive to be underweight again.
* If you were overweight when you were 21 you probably shouldn't strive to be overweight again.
But if you're in that HUUUGE in-between where you have that pair of jeans you wore in college and really liked but now don't fit into anymore and rationalized it as "well I'm not young anymore" you are the target of this messaging. Because if you want stay healthy as you age and "slow down" putting on weight is the worst thing you could do.
- browningstreet 5y agoI'll go one more: if your waist is bigger than your chest, you're not in good shape. There are ways to use and abuse this rule, but it holds pretty true.
- commandlinefan 5y agoThere are bound to be a lot of people who don't WANT this to be true and will look for any possible evidence that it might not be.