3 ms·
This is an interesting point I like to bring up. The incredible integrated suffering of the NK people at some point will surpass a single (theoretical) turning
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
This is an interesting point I like to bring up. The incredible integrated suffering of the NK people at some point will surpass a single (theoretical) turning point event that MacArthur envisioned.
Of course, the ends don’t justify the means, lest one uses this reasoning to destroy everyone you feel is about to do great harm, we are only gifted with hindsight.
- CamperBob2 5y agoI actually think that particular end would have justified the means, at least at the time. However, the larger effect of normalizing the use of nuclear attacks as instruments of policy would almost certainly have been worse for everyone in the long run. My guess is that the same reasoning that led von Neumann to advocate a decisive blow against the pre-H bomb Soviet Union would have led him to oppose MacArthur's ambition towards Manchuria. His position on the Korean conflict may be on record somewhere, but I haven't run across it.