3 ms·
I am very surprised in this conclusion... Normally if you have two high voltage wires being immersed in water, a large current flows, vaporising the water, an
by londons_explore 5y ago
I am very surprised in this conclusion... Normally if you have two high voltage wires being immersed in water, a large current flows, vaporising the water, and then the current stops when all the water has been evaporated.
For the current to flow for long enough to heat the battery packs to cause a fire, there must have been a jet of water flowing for a long period of time. And no fusible links between that place and the battery.
It really seems like either very bad luck, or bad system design, or both.
- algo_trader 5y agoOff topic: can we do a floating (mega-)mega-pack, and use passive water cooling? This should help costs, efficiency AND prolong life time Of course issues with sweet vs salt water
- londons_explore 5y agoSure you can do it, but it won't be reliable or cost effective. Passive water cooling in natural water tends to lead to seaweed and all kinds of sea creatures blocking up all heat exchange surfaces. In the case of a megapack, cooling isn't critical to safety - as long as you're happy to stop using a battery when too hot, it won't get hotter. The reason to cool is is so you can keep using the battery.
- mannykannot 5y agoThe article puts it this way: "ESV found a Megapack cooling system leak caused a short circuit resulting in overheating that led to a fire in a nearby battery compartment." Nothing here implies that the damaging heat generation occurred at the location of the short circuit. It could have been at any point in the new current path created by the short circuit, depending on its resistance and the share of the overload current it carried.
- michaelt 5y agoA cooling system for something that's on fire sounds like exactly where there should be a jet of water flowing for a long period of time :)