6 ms·
Google’s dominance in ad tech supply chain harms businesses and consumers
- roenxi 5y agoOh no the poor corporations are struggling to show me ads. Whatever shall I do. I'd like to see Google kicked out of Australia on national security grounds. But I don't think them being better at advertising than everyone else is a reason.
- qsort 5y agoThat's not what the article is saying. The report finds that Google has used its position to preference its own services and shield them from competition. For example, Google prevents rival ad tech services from accessing ads on YouTube, providing its own ad tech services with an important advantage. It's hardly news that Google does that stuff, but unlike showing ads it's actually illegal, and therefore reasonable grounds for regulatory action.
- roenxi 5y agoSo? Why are my tax dollars being wasted on efforts to force Google to show random ads for poor quality services on YouTube? The people who care should waste their own money on this fools errand. I don't particularly want to see any ads. If Google does their own thing that is cool. > ...but unlike showing ads it's actually illegal... The law is stupid and they should change it.
- bottled_poe 5y agoBased on the tone of your comments, it doesn’t seem like you are open to a reasonable discussion on the topic. Why are you even commenting? We’re you hoping for backup? Like a zeitgeist echo chamber? Grow up.
- Ygg2 5y agoRandom ads of poor quality. So just like Google ads?
- over_bridge 5y agoWho else will follow me around the internet with ads for products I've already purchased and will never ever purchase again?
- CPLX 5y agoThere's a different between "better at" and "anti-competitive"
- einpoklum 5y ago> I'd like to see Google kicked out of Australia on national security grounds. I believe you make too strong of an assumption of Australian sovereignty and independence relative to the US. Australia is too subservient to the US to declare a national security interest that contradicts the commercial interests of a key US corporation like Google. No, if anything, the direction is the opposite one with the AUKUS military alliance against China. Australia will take nuclear subs plus Google dominance. ... unless some kind of radical political change takes place down under. IIANM, Australia doesn't have a single strong anti-Imperialist political party at the federal level.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe notion of Australia being “anti-imperialist” is rich - they are a product of imperialism and can’t really exist long term without a sponsor.
- einpoklum 5y agoThe Australian state and the people of Australia are not the same thing. Even though Australia was founded as an imperial colony... 1. It was a colony of Britain, not the US. 2. It's been a couple of hundreds of years by now. Many generations. 3. The internal social relations are class-stratified just like any capitalist democracy. Also, I don't see why it should not be able to exist long without a sponsor.
- cblconfederate 5y agoThis is like 10 years late
- dzonga 5y agowith this being australia, chances are the power will shift from google to murdoch owned companies. however, the monopoly power of google is there for everyone to see. no way, should one company be controlling both sides of an auction market
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI'd honestly rank Rupert Murdoch up there with the worst human beings who have ever lived. It may seem strange on the surface to rank him alongside the tyrants and warlords of human history, but history will condemn him utterly for building one of world's most powerful influence machines and using it to promote climate change denial on an unprecedented scale.
- ethbr0 5y agoYou'll love this then. From Fox Corp's proxy statement, to be presented at the upcoming annual meeting: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1754301/000119312521276133/d181730ddef14a.htm#rom181730_42 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1754301/000119312521... "PROPOSAL NO. 5: TRANSITION TO PUBLIC BENEFIT CORPORATION Shareholders request our Board of Directors take steps necessary to amend our certificate of incorporation and, if necessary, bylaws [...] to become a public benefit corporation [...]. Shareholders request that one of the public benefits included in the amendment be provision of the Company’s viewers with an accurate understanding of current events through the exercise of journalistic integrity [...]" I thought it was a pretty classy troll. Credit to Matt Levine for the pointer. And in all fairness, the insurgents do put a veneer of reasoning over why it would make sense: "The vast majority of our diversified shareholders lose when companies harm the economy, because the value of diversified portfolios rises and falls with GDP. While a concentrated holder may profit when the Company inflicts costs on society by emphasizing viewership over accuracy, diversified shareholders internalize those costs."
- BoxOfRain 5y agoOne has to admire the bare-faced cheek on display here!
- Pxtl 5y agoI.... what? What? So the argument is that Google has to support alternate advertising middleware on their platforms? Like, it's not about "they don't take ads from X" but "they don't let other middle-men get involved deploying advertising onto their platforms"? This doesn't make any sense to me. There's a lot to hate about internet advertising, but most of that concerns the race-to-the-bottom problems... and forcing platforms to allow alternate ad providers onto their services seems like a good way to make it worse. Isn't this a compelled speech issue? Shouldn't I have control over what ads run on my site?
- wilde 5y agoIf YouTube were spun out tomorrow, would they make the same choices in how they source ads? If Google’s exchange is actually servicing the highest quality ads, then great. But if they’re only using it because it’s Google’s it becomes more suspect.
- minhazm 5y agoEven if they spun off the most likely scenario is that YouTube would just create their own ad infrastructure just like every other major tech company. They're not going to give away some of their margins, especially at that scale. Right now they have the advantage that their parent company Google deals with the ads infrastructure for them without any hit to their margins since all the revenue rolls up to the same company anyway.
- wilde 5y agoEven that could be a better outcome. When I worked at Microsoft we often had to “dogfood” some other team’s product even if it was vastly inferior to the front runner. Orgs past a certain size give their managers too many brownie points for making “one solution” that serves the whole company poorly.
- anaganisk 5y agoIts almost like. since A major real-estate provider in a country who owns so much land, must be able to make his own laws in those lands.
- Jensson 5y ago> For example, Google prevents rival ad tech services from accessing ads on YouTube How would this work, will Australians see non Google ads on Youtube in the future? And if so, then I assume those ad companies will pay money to youtube to put ads there, who sets that rate? And how do we ensure that hosting youtube videos is still profitable under those ad rates, maybe it runs under so tight margins that giving away money to other ad companies would make it unprofitable again? I don't really see how this would work at all. What are they thinking? And even ignoring all of the above, who thinks that putting others ads on youtube would benefit consumers?
- kqvamxurcagg 5y agoIt's not difficult to see how the market could be reformed. YouTube would be required to offer ad space to Google ad customers and third party network customers at the same market rate. If this rate is market set in real time then that's one solution. The problem is Google (and other big tech companies) control and restricts all aspects of what is being termed the 'supply chain'. That restricts competition and reduces transparency.
- Jensson 5y agoBut Google and Youtube are the same company, they share many of the same engineers and servers and are bunded in the same annual reports. Not sure how you would get a market rate from that. What you are suggesting is that we split Google up from Youtube, but that is not on the table. Edit: Lastly I am not sure how being able to put your own ads on your own website is bad for consumers. It means that people has to go via Google to put ads on a Google website. How can anyone view that as "anti competitive"? I mean, Google could just create a separate ad service for Youtube, say that Youtube now uses its own service and therefore is not anti competitive. Wouldn't that just circumvent this law completely? Or is the goal to be able to force arbitrary ads on any website?
- kqvamxurcagg 5y agoI've dealt with this many times in the past. This is known as a carve-out or regulated entity status. Different parts of a group have to deal with each other at an arms-length basis and provide those same terms to other independent companies. The timesheets of engineers or digital infrastructure isn't a barrier to making this happen, although it might involve some work for external APIs, authentication and reporting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andersonrkton 5y agoBlockchain and ad tech… is anyone exploring this?