5 ms·
Although the TGV was purportedly for everybody, one of the things which long hampered it is the historical and technocratic notion of Paris being the sole hub o
by masklinn 5y ago
Although the TGV was purportedly for everybody, one of the things which long hampered it is the historical and technocratic notion of Paris being the sole hub of the country: while the first TGV section opened in 1981, the first section which was not subordinate to Paris (either going to it or directly extending a line coming from Paris) was the LGV Rhin-Rhone in 2011.
To this day, if you want to travel between south-east and south-west france, you can go straight through using intercity trains (which takes 6h between Marseilles and Bordeaux) or through Paris on the TGV (which… also takes 6h).
The distance between Marseilles and Bordeaux is about 650km, about the same as Paris - Bordeaux and significantly shorter than Paris - Marseilles (800km), both of which are about 3h TGV from Paris (resp. 2:30 for Bordeaux and 3:30 for Marseilles).
- andix 5y agoThis is probably one of the biggest problems of TGVl But at least it opens up France to people from Paris and London (region), the two biggest cities of Western Europe.
- samhw 5y ago> one of the things which long hampered it is the historical and technocratic notion of Paris being the sole hub of the country Is it really the 'historical and technocratic notion' which influenced it, or just the raw fact that it is the hub of the country, the place from or to which most people want to travel? Sure, that fact may itself have been determined by all kinds of historical and/or technocratic notions, but I see no reason why the TGV builders need to have been musing on history.
- masklinn 5y ago> Is it really the 'historical and technocratic notion' which influenced it, or just the raw fact that it is the hub of the country, the place from or to which most people want to travel? The former, concentrating state power in Paris, and limiting (or even outright suppressing) the importance and influence of the rest of the country (especially the southern half) has been a constant theme since the Bourbons: they underwent the project of moving france from a decentralised feudal state to a centralised absolute monarchy. This theme of centralisation of power remained a constant until very late in the 20th century e.g. regional languages remained pretty actively suppressed until the 50s (Loi Deixonne which allowed some of them to be taught at all). Even then that allowance remained limited until the 80s at the earliest. To this day, france has signed but not ratified the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages. > I see no reason why the TGV builders need to have been musing on history. Because even if they had considered the idea (which they probably had not) it would have been shot down as completely useless by pollies.
- rewma 5y ago> The former, concentrating state power in Paris, and limiting (or even outright suppressing) the importance and influence of the rest of the country (especially the southern half) has been a constant theme since the Bourbons: they underwent the project of moving france from a decentralised feudal state to a centralised absolute monarchy. This is a great call, and it should be noted that the same pattern has also been adopted in Spain, with the nation's hub in Madrid and the spokes in regional capitals. The notable exception is Spain's stretches of the Mediterranean corridor, which is a part of the trans-european transport network. Still, notably these stretches do not add further connections through Barcelona.
- anthk 5y agoMadrid and Paris are blackholes. The Mediterranean coast and Barcelona/Valencia/Balearics are "safe" from that because the mentality of tourism/media creation (Catalonia was THE powerhouse of printed press/tv/media producing and so on) helped to crash down the Francoist regime (tourist money made most of fascists turn a blind eye to "impudity"). And OFC the Basque Country being a industrial powerhouse makes Spain overall a more balanced country than France.
- bambax 5y agoYes. IIRC we used to have math problems called "distance SNCF" where you were asked to calculate the distance between two cities, and then the "train distance". The difference is, with the train distance you have to go through Paris, no matter what is the actual distance between the cities.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAnd not to mention that many of these lines don't even actually connect in Paris. You often have to take the metro or RER from one station to another. Not easily done with luggage during rush hour.
- zwaps 5y agoPros and Cons. Consider ICE, the German equivalent to the TGV. Germany is not centralized, so you find ICE connections all over the place. But few are as good or as high speed on the whole track as the ones coming out of Paris. Here, centrality made it easier to build and expand a high speed net that is much less piecemeal. In Germany, you can go with ICE from any midrange town to another. And yet, only a handful of sections are 300kph
- anthk 5y agoAnd now compare the orography of France and Germany, please. Do not head down here to Spain, because you'll get a mountainous nightmare.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFrance has had Paris at the hub of its railway system ("chemins de fer" --- paths of iron) pretty much from day one. This is a series of railway maps of Europe from the 1870s through 2000. Local routes eventually in-filled decentralised waypoints, but the main lines and high-speed (TGV) lines continue to operate with Paris as a major hub. https://europeanrailroads.blogs.wm.edu/maps-and-graphs/railway-network-in-europe/ https://europeanrailroads.blogs.wm.edu/maps-and-graphs/railw... This proved problematic for France during the world wars, when the railroads improved the capacity of invading forces to focus in on the capital whilst defenders were unable to mobilise between other points other than by travellling through the (variously: under-attack or occupied) central hub.