3 ms·
> I think doing a PhD is one of the worst things a person can do them financially long term. I think gambling is one of the few that ranks higher than PhD. They
by BeetleB 5y ago
> I think doing a PhD is one of the worst things a person can do them financially long term. I think gambling is one of the few that ranks higher than PhD. They lose the most critical part of life they must be earning and saving to harness the power of compounding to become financially secure.
Financially, I don't disagree.
The amusing thing is that I often would say the exact same thing on the other end of the coin. Going to industry right after your undergrad is one of the worst things one can do intellectually. People who want to grow intellectually[1] typically will grow more in their grad school years than most people will in their life. I can clearly see it when I look at my friends who did not opt for grad school.
And even within a particular discipline, for a lot of disciplines, there is virtually no way you can attain that particular knowledge while having a full time job. Life gets busy.
It ultimately comes down to values. Some prefer the money, others the knowledge. Personally, I appreciate the adage: Money comes and goes, but knowledge tends to remain with you.
> On top, they learn no marketable skills that can get them a job out in industry or corporations.
People who plan and aim properly for a career in academia probably pick up more marketable skills than the average industry employee. Self promotion and networking matters more in academia than in industry. There's also stuff like grant writing, public speaking, etc.
[1] Not all people who pursue a PhD want to grow intellectually, but a significant portion do.
- brystarg 5y ago> Going to industry right after your undergrad is one of the worst things one can do intellectually What does this mean? Do you mean this as psychological maturity? Domain knowledge expertise?
- barry-cotter 5y agoExtremely few people outside academia are (1) world class at anything, even in a tiny subfield (2) advance the state of the art (3) can explain it in a way clear enough that you can reliably learn something from what they wrote about what they did and how they did it. That combination describes what a doctoral disserataion is.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThe opposite is true in my field, which is half-way between CS and humanities. I've read a few hundred PhD dissertations now and most of them are really not great. Not a few are more jargon than substance, covering up mediocre ideas with a sugar frosting of math symbols and bizarre wordy academic pseudo-abstraction which obfuscates simple ideas instead of clarifying complex thoughts. A few are straight out pandering and careerism, with style and content apparently designed to appeal to a specific supervisor. I was considering a PhD and the quality of the work was the biggest factor that decided me against it. To be fair it's a fairly niche field. But even so - literally only a handful of those dissertations come close to matching your criteria.
- Derbasti 5y agoThis is an important point. Doing a PhD is not a great choice financially (usually). But where else can you invest a few years into personal growth and attaining knowledge on your own terms? As much as my PhD was stressful and grueling at times, I wouldn't want to miss those years for the personal growth they facilitated. But then, that might be survivor bias speaking... I'll have to talk to my former colleagues who quit the program to figure that one out.
- bumby 5y agoOut of curiosity, how old were you when you did your PhD? I wonder if the personal growth is more meaningful when one does the program during more formative years. I started my PhD rather late after quite a few years in industry. Honestly, I felt like it held back some personal growth because there was more structure than self-guided learning
- Derbasti 5y agoI was 30-35. I had worked in the industry for a few years before that as well. But working at a company taught me very different things than the PhD did. It feels like I learned to program at the company, and I learned to think at the university.