3 ms·
People say that about communism too. I'm not open to debate any of the tankies I know are on HN, but if a paradigm brings utopia if implemented properly, and mi
by bitwize 5y ago
People say that about communism too. I'm not open to debate any of the tankies I know are on HN, but if a paradigm brings utopia if implemented properly, and misery otherwise, and there have been no known utopia-yielding instances of the paradigm despite repeated attempts, it's time to consider that maybe misery is inherent to the paradigm.
- shados 5y agoYou're not wrong. Communism implemented perfectly would also work beautifully. It just can't. The main difference here is that Scrum is not nearly as complicated to implement. Though the issue is the same. There's always someone somewhere who thinks the process doesn't apply to them and the whole thing falls apart. I did work in one company that had a fairly well implemented Scrum, and it did work pretty well. I've never seen it replicated though, so for all practical purpose, it's exactly as you say: it's not worth trying because it only works when done perfectly, and that almost never happen.