3 ms·
> AFAIK we already simulate brains of silk worms or some such thing? There is research into mapping the complete neural structure of a nematode worm called C.
by tsimionescu 5y ago
> AFAIK we already simulate brains of silk worms or some such thing?
There is research into mapping the complete neural structure of a nematode worm called C. elegans [0] - one of the simplest known organisms that has some kind of a nervous system (the entire worm has 959 cells for hermaphrodite individuals, or 1035 for males; of these, 302 are neurons - and yes, this is not a typo, these are not hundreds or thousands of cells, just cells - that's how tiny it is). Its entire nervous system has been mapped out, including all connections, in [0]. Note that its neural cells are not like mammal neurons, they lack many of the known processes present in even a single mammal neuron.
However, the project to simulate this simplest of organisms, OpenWorm [1], has not yet achieved its goals (which is also somewhat reduced - they only intend to simulate the motor system initially, not the entire organism).
Silkworms (which are moths) are waaaay beyond any imaginable simulation capability at the moment.
[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6889226/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6889226/
[1] https://github.com/openworm/OpenWorm/milestones https://github.com/openworm/OpenWorm/milestones
- staticassertion 5y agoRight, I was just bringing that up as an example of simulating without understanding. The paper is talking about taking another approach. Whether it will work or not is not something I could comment on. Another example is how we have a very imperfect model for the universe, and yet we use our models to make strikingly accurate predictions. Huge gaps in our knowledge exist, but that doesn't stop us from using approximations to do interesting things.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Right, I was just bringing that up as an example of simulating without understanding. But that's just it - first they spent some time understanding how the system works,painstakingly mapping out each connection, the role of each individual cell (literally), they studied the chemistry inside each neural cell etc. The simulation effort started after all of this was done. If anything, I would say OpenWorm is a counter-example to the idea that you can simulate such a system without understanding it. Similarly, with our model of the universe, while gaps exist, the extent of those gaps and approximations is mostly known, and the areas affected by those gaps are exactly where we can't make predictions (e.g. the internal structure of a black hole). Not to mention, we had a massive piece of good luck there: it turns out that particles are described by linear equations, which have extremely nice properties for approximations. Already with GR we are in much worse territory with it's nonlinear equations, but at least we understand these well enough to create some linear approximations - or so we think.