5 ms·
I believe the trend toward a peaceful society has led to an imbalance of power based on age. When life was violent, it stabilized wealth concentration issues by
by renewiltord 5y ago
I believe the trend toward a peaceful society has led to an imbalance of power based on age. When life was violent, it stabilized wealth concentration issues by periodically resetting the power of entrenched interests.
Today, the old disproportionately control power and they direct that power towards their own protection. This is true of 80 yr olds. But it is also true of 50 yr olds. And even 30 yr olds.
The COVID crisis response is one such example. Overbearing responses were put into place primarily because the danger was to old people. Concerns over this very outcome were handwaved away with low likelihood counterfactuals.
Alternatives exist in some other cultures. We are familiar with the Fukushima Skilled Veteran Corps https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-13598607 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-13598607 but there are people who have a similar perspective who occupy this world.
My parents are surgeons in their sixties and they continue to practise during this crisis and do not advocate for the degree of total lockdown that is so popular. They do not advocate for closed schools. I would rather be them than be like risk-averse 70 yr olds saying that life should pause (but not their pensions).
I’m going to go ahead and say it: intransigent old people might be the greatest threat to humanity’s long term survival through their normalcy bias, grip on power, and fear of change. I hope that as I grow older I, too, manage to prioritize the next generation over myself.
- notyourday 5y ago> Overbearing responses were put into place primarily because the danger was to old people. Not only that - but these responses were put in place by the old people to protect the old people at the expense of the young people
- opheliate 5y agoDo you believe that, if the numbers had been reversed, and COVID was much more fatal to children and young people than it was to the old, lockdowns wouldn’t have happened? That seems to be the implication of your post, but I find it difficult to imagine that being the result.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WhereIsSweden 5y agoCheck the Swine Flu epidemic
- _-david-_ 5y agoI'm not who you were responding to but I think if covid was more fatal towards children than adults we would have seen far less opposition to lock downs. I am not sure what the current number is but at the beginning the average age of death from covid was around the average life expectancy in the US. I am not saying we shouldn't take actions to avoid getting old people sick, but it is hard to justify completely stalling the education of children in that situation. If children were dying from at high rates people would have found hurting their education to be more acceptable.
- ls65536 5y agoThis reminds me of an old Greek proverb: "A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in."