22 ms·
New credit card rules in India: recurring card payments to be affected
- abhijat 5y agoThis is a fairly old article, and the title suggests there is a recent ban on recurring charges. Am I missing something here?
- aero-glide2 5y agoHere's one from last week. https://wap.business-standard.com/article/finance/rbi-s-firm-stand-on-payments-sends-banks-card-issuers-into-a-tizzy-121092301381_1.html https://wap.business-standard.com/article/finance/rbi-s-firm...
- Bang2Bay 5y agoMuch more detailed article from 6 months ago. https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-why-auto-payment-for-ott-platforms-may-not-go-through-from-april-1-7251728/ https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-why-au...
- alarak 5y agoThe title is misleading, this is a very old article.
- Brajeshwar 5y agoI'm extremely sorry; the title is correct with what's happening with India's RBI[1] regulations banning all recurring card charges from next month. But I have added the wrong link from the wrong tab. This new Safari is pretty confusing. Here is a more relevant article - https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/recurring-card-payments-to-be-affected-as-new-credit-debit-card-rules-kick-in-from-october-1/articleshow/86552869.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/financ... 1. https://www.rbi.org.in https://www.rbi.org.in
- azundo 5y agoThe article you linked suggests that recurring card charges that use two factor authentication will not be banned. So I think the title is still overstating.
- Brajeshwar 5y ago2FA with Cards in India is an OTP (One Time Password) that sends us an SMS Message on our phone. Which means, even if the recurring happens, you still need to have access to the site and then enter the OTP at that time to make it work.
- pgo 5y agoIt's a one time authorization
- zodvik 5y agoThat isn't how it will work - First charge needs a AFA and it will setup a mandate - Subsequent charges will use that mandate and work without 2FA - Cardholders need to be notified in advance of a debit and be given an option to cancel What's breaking now for most services is handling the third part
- rolph 5y agoactual title == [The RBI’s stringent rules on recurring payments are driving away India’s software companies] the actual title of a submission is subject to HN guidelines, the current title [ndia bans all form of Recurring Card Charges] is in no way similar] highly editorialized titles create assumptions and non sequitorial context before anyone else even reads the article. you should talk to dang about this at HN@ycombinator.com
- bluehatbrit 5y agoAssuming dang doesn't get to it sooner, you could email hn@ycombinator.com to ask for the link to be updated.
- ssivark 5y ago
- billfruit 5y agoHow are other countries dealing with recurring card charges? Is there a reasoning why Indian regulations in this regard should be different from those in the USA, for example?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe US is a very poor example in how to implement financial service regulations (a better example would be Europe, where they have instant payments and cram down interchange fees with regulation). Non-Indian software companies are accustom to business friendly recurring payment policies, not the more consumer-focused financial regulations India has. From OP's relevant article link [1]: > He adds that this directive caters to two problems. Discontinuing standing instruction to a merchant was a task earlier while some asked for a letter by post asking for the discontinuation. > Moreover, credit cards were mainly used for recurring payments while debit cards weren't as much in use. So, it would seem that the regulator is attempting to make it harder for businesses to lock customers into recurring payments they don't want, and to encourage debit card use versus credit card use. I imagine this is keeping in line with India not wanting capitalistic colonialism, which is why the Indian central bank kneecapped US payment networks [2] in support of their own instant payment system (UPI [3]). Developing countries don't want to pay unnecessary drag on their economic systems to rent seeking first world corporations, if they can avoid it. [1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/recurring-card-payments-to-be-affected-as-new-credit-debit-card-rules-kick-in-from-october-1/articleshow/86552869.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/financ... [2] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-57817618 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-57817618 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface
- billfruit 5y agoPreventing a consumer from subscribing something they want through an automated recurring payment may not be a consumer friendly thing as well. Perhaps the inability of the Indian framework to appropriately deal with fraud and other nefarious uses like misleading the consumer, etc is prompting such blanket measures. In other words, is potentially throwing the baby with the bathwater, a good policy?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sinyug 5y agoThis is not a ban, and has been in the works for a long time with at least one six-month extension granted that I know of.[1] What the RBI has done is introduce AFA (additional factor authentication) for recurring transactions.[2] But this is India and we like to do things one day before any deadline expires. That explains the panic. [1] https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=12051&Mode=0 https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=1205... [2] https://support.stripe.com/questions/important-updates-to-rbi-regulations-on-recurring-card-payments-in-india https://support.stripe.com/questions/important-updates-to-rb...
- athenot 5y ago> But this is India and we like to do things one day before any deadline expires. That explains the panic. This made me laugh. But rest assured, things aren't any better in the US when some regulation comes with plenty notice. (Thinking most recently about the Cures Act where healthcare info must be accessible to patient without putting up blocks; many healthcare providers only started thinking about it at the last minute)
- Bang2Bay 5y agoNeeded initiative, given that a large part of the population is not tech savvy.
- cfgghsj 5y agoWhile I didn't work on indian regulations, I've worked directly on 2FA/OTP with recurring charges. For this regulation, the recurring charge must be initiated with an OTP code, but subsequent charges may happen automatically. There should also be an exception process to allow preexisting standing instructions to continue. This article has details of the actual regulation: https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-why-auto-payment-for-ott-platforms-may-not-go-through-from-april-1-7251728/ https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-why-au...
- Brajeshwar 5y agoI believe it started that way but now everyone has just stopped recurring. I have already got email notifications from AWS (India), my phone provider, etc. that we have to pay manually from next month.
- sinyug 5y ago> everyone has just stopped recurring Every one had two years to implement the e-mandate system.[1] What does it say about Amazon, your phone provider and your card issuer that they haven't been able to do it in time and decided, instead, to pass the buck to you, the customer? [1] https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=11668 https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=1166...
- zodvik 5y agoYes, because most services haven't met the full scope of the RBI circular yet - sending pre-debit notification, self serve mandate revocation, etc
- jeswin 5y agoServices handling recurring payments need to compulsorily have a cancel button. Here's my story with nytimes today. There's no cancellation button in the app or the website. There's a "chat with agent"option, but it doesn't work. So they ask you to call an agent, on the phone. After ten minutes of being "next in line", I get to speak to someone. He doesn't let me cancel, but takes down my details and transfers to "Management". I was seventh in line. But after 10 mins, I was eighth in line. After 12 mins, I was ninth in line. I was finally able to get hold of someone and cancel it, after holding for 25 minutes. This should be illegal.
- ilamont 5y agoBoston Globe and telecom providers in the states do the same thing - force you to talk with someone (I think the term is "retention specialist"). Naturally after having introductory rates expire and prices jacked up 50% or more you're angry and want to get out, but they have all kinds of new promotions or rates you can sign onto.
- jdofaz 5y agoI've never been willing to try a subscription with them due to stories like this. It actually taught me to do a quick search on how to cancel something before I subscribe. If I have to talk to someone I'm probably not ever going to subscribe.
- munk-a 5y agoIn particular - services should never be asymetrical in barriers to subscribe vs. unsubscribe - that's clearly a predatory tactic that exists to trap a portion of users as unwilling subscribers. I will never support a company that operates in that manner - no matter how little or much I appreciate their services.
- ozzythecat 5y agoThis reminds me of my story with LA fitness. They closed down their only location that’s in a sane driving distance to me and said I could use my membership at the next closest location without paying extra, as if they were doing me a favor. After calling them to cancel, they refused to cancel on the phone and insisted I go into a physical location… well, it’s 30 miles away, and I didn’t have a car and I’m on crutches. Getting around was very difficult for me. In the meantime, they refused to even accept my phone call as a request to cancel. I was charged for three extra months, until I finally paid $100+ round trip to Uber to their location and cancel in person. LA Fitness is a soulless leech, and the fact that company is allowed to stay in business is testament to a corrupt government system.
- jhugo 5y agoStripe emailed me about this the other day, and are handling it pretty seamlessly. Recurring charges are not being banned. An additional factor of authentication is required above a certain threshold, and pre-debit notifications need to be sent. They're sensible rules which more countries should adopt.
- some1else 5y agoThis article is from 2014. Have the rules not changed since? This article indicates otherwise: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/your-recurring-payments-wont-fail-from-april-1-as-rbi-extends-deadline/articleshow/81778029.cms?from=mdr https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/your-re...
- remus 5y agoStripe have recently been sending out emails related to problems with recurring payments for customers in India, so I guess it's still an issue.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoRules are being implemented from 1st October and not just for credit cards, for ALL transactions that are autonomous. Source: I live in India and got an sms from my bank stating the same. This makes my netflix subscription easy to cancel.. usually I used to be lazy to go and cancel but every month my account goes on hold! That's a life saver as I'm saturated with netflix now and it's wrong to make everything bloody subscription.
- bgro 5y agoI remember Xbox Live in like mid 2000's letting you sign up on the website but there was no cancel option. You had to call in. You were usually on wait for an hour, and then an hour of being harassed by the sales people. In theory, I don't see anything that prevents them from just endlessly passing you in a loop to prevent you from cancelling like some sort of video game mechanic. This was also when there was not really any possible home VOIP or landlines, and cell phone minutes were very expensive. The only real solution was to buy prepaid xbox cards.
- munk-a 5y agoThis isn't particularly helpful advice at this point - but there was a heavy overlap between most people still having a landline and VOIP options. For a long time google let you dial a phone directly from the gmail web UI - it might still let you do that if you're on the legacy feature (they did recently drop incoming call support though).
- superasn 5y agoGoogle just emailed me too and I have to pay these manually or face service disruption. I have auto billing setup at so many places like porkbun, many Saas services, amazon, Google, digitalocean, etc. God knows how many reminders I will have to add and how much time I will have to waste every month paying these bills by hand now and I hope I don't miss any. I can only wish like digitalocean, amazon google too provide provisions to add account balance so I can add money as failsafe.
- KorematsuFredt 5y agoIt is a huge legal hassle at the moment in India. For amounts greater than 10K they have to KYC you. KYC is not only complex but also needs to be renewed on regular basis and failing to do it can lead to several punishment from Indian government.
- akshayB 5y agoThis is super old new 2014 article. One of the biggest problems in India is most of the people are not well educated on differences of credit card vs debit cards. Also there is little to no fraud projection offered to the customers and that's why government is enforcing two factor authentication. If anything happens and you loose money from bank account due to debit card transaction bank will provide you no help what so ever. Its almost like you lost all the money.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoI got an sms from my bank today that scheduled transactions will not be honoured by the bank.. with effect 1st oct So yes circular is old but it's being implemented on 1st oct..
- pseingatl 5y agoJust got a call from the IRS, apparently they have outsourced their enforcement to call centers in India, they asked me to purchase Apple gift cards in order to pay what they claimed was a fine I owed. I thought it a little odd... The IRS also accepts Google Play cards. There is an enormous amount of Internet fraud in India, and coming out of India. Until the country learns to police itself, I have no sympathy for those who claim SaaS subscription collections otherwise is a "problem." As Rick (of "Rick and Morty") once said: "tough titty."
- pseingatl 5y agoThere's a web site that provides debit cards with a $ limit, so you set up the subscription on the card and simply fail to fund the card when the subscription expires. Can't remember the name of it, though.
- snambi 5y agoI think what India did here helps customers. Ofcourse, it may not help service providers. Anyway, customers should decide on the payment. If the customer doesn't pay, company should stop the service.
- tpl 5y agoAm I wrong to say that it's not fair to say they banned all forms of recurring charges? I thought that most of the new regs were around informing the person about to be charged that it is coming and better handling for making the charges stop.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoNot wrong!! These scheduled transaction use our laziness/ inattentiveness to mint money from us.
- eatbitseveryday 5y agoI wonder if you can take control yourself (albeit not real solutions) by: - reporting your card lost, requesting replacement - (with Apple Card) requesting a new number - disabling / locking the card temporarily during the period they'd try to charge you - use a service that provides a "virtual" card for such vendors, and then just deleting it (e.g. PayPal Key) Yes there is collateral damage in the process (other payments get dinged, you have to wait for a new card, etc.) but perhaps it would work, and you wouldn't lose money?
- rataata_jr 5y agoI can't auto pay for DO now. Hmm.
- vinay_ys 5y agoLink is 2 years old article.
- 1024core 5y ago7 years old. It's from 2014.
- srathi 5y agoWillow.tv is a major culprit here. There is no cancellation button on the website, and you are required to email a support person multiple times (back and forth with retention offers) for cancellation. They are in violation of CA law that prohibits this behavior.
- Mustache 5y agoI use privacy.com to create virtual debit cards for all online payments, especially recurring ones. I can set limts on monthly, annual or one time charges and cancel it myself at anytime. the other added benefit is that if you lose your debit card you only have to change the number with privacy.com you don't have to go to each vender and update to a new card number.
- zburatorul 5y agoI highly recommend this service as well.
- anaganisk 5y agoWorks only in US, when u suggest something make sure if it works for the rest of the World. Or at-least please do mention about the limitation. US =/= World.
- KorematsuFredt 5y agoI am so pissed with this rule. Every month I have to login into my AWS account and pay the bills manually even if it is just < $10.
- nikolay 5y agoThere are a lot of shady merchant schemes regarding recurring payments. In the past, I knew hidden charges (i.e., recurring charges I fail to notice) would eventually stop as my credit card would eventually expire in their system. By shady merchants (like AAA, for example, which otherwise claims to be a reputable company), for my "convenience" update by guessing my expired credit card's new expiration date! Thus, they keep charging me forever! So, I'm sorry, recurring charges as both convenient and borderline scams! If I was aware of each upcoming payment and I had to approve it, then I would be spending a lot less money each month!
- perryizgr8 5y agoCredit card issuers in India have not been as proactive as they should have been to protect consumers from scammy subscriptions. I was bitten by such an app on the play store that charged my card $50 after a 3 day trial. Google wouldn't do anything about it, and my card issuer said "if you willingly entered your card info then we can't do anything about it". Only I entered my info into Google, long before I downloaded the app. Google should have asked me before charging the card. Consent to charge and the charge itself should be done at the same time. So I'm OK with this. Either behave responsibly or get regulated. Sounds fair.