3 ms·
Science can't be logically inconsistent. If a system is logically inconsistent then you can prove anything from it, so there would be nothing for science to exp
by roenxi 5y ago
Science can't be logically inconsistent. If a system is logically inconsistent then you can prove anything from it, so there would be nothing for science to explain - everything would follow from the inconsistency.
Science is comfortable with uncertainty, but not with things that are illogical. It has to be logical, and the scientists have to accept some sort of logic to give theories a better-worse hierarchy.
- Koshkin 5y ago> then you can prove anything from it Except most of sciences take experiment as the criterion of truth rather than logical inference. Real-world science can almost always be expected to be inconsistent - simply because each scientific theory is a "local" approximation, and theories developed for different areas of the same science are not required to be mutually consistent in order to be useful. One (in)famous example is quantum mechanics and general relativity.
- boris_m 5y agoIt's not "experiment rather than logical inference" it's experiment and logical inference.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- coolgeek 5y agoThere seems to be a markdown error (and a grammatical error) in: > This is it about axiom schemas and *rules of inference are almost the same thing except they allow us to actually distill the conclusion from the premises.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 5y agoScience doesn't even have axiomatic foundations. The consequence of two competing scientific theories is not logical explosion...