9 ms·
> The Post publicizes material obtained through hacking with caution, only after verifying its authenticity and ascertaining that there is news value in bringin
by h2odragon 5y ago
> The Post publicizes material obtained through hacking with caution, only after verifying its authenticity and ascertaining that there is news value in bringing such information to light.
Sure you do.
So let me just check here: Political purity as an employment requirement... Firing people for this is fine, right?
What happens when the popular politics change?
The "Moral Majority" folks were accused of wanting to be everything the Left has become.
- mcphage 5y agoI think criticizing people for running websites like “theholocaustisfake” is less like “attacking people for having bad thoughts” and a bit more like “attacking people for poisoning the well”.
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoThat's what you think. The person running that web site probably thinks differently. If they came to power, they would perhaps censor sites that promote the holocaust. See how that works?
- KptMarchewa 5y agoThat's why you need to stop them before they came to power. World learned that in 1933.
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoWhere you alive in 1933? I wasn't. So all I know about the Holocaust is just what somebody else wrote about it. I generally don't like taking things as gospel. I don't generally doubt the Holocaust (I have no reason to), but I think it should be possible to discuss even the details of the holocaust. To me it is rather the demand that certain beliefs may not be questioned that enables things like fascists rising to power. (To me it doesn't matter that much if the Holocaust was real or not - either way mass killings of people should obviously be avoided).
- watwut 5y ago> I think it should be possible to discuss even the details of the holocaust Details of Holocaust are allowed to be discussed and are discussed regularly. Discussing details of holocaust and holocaust denier are two different things, turns out.
- notanzaiiswear 5y ago"It turns out" - how so? Maybe some people simply take an interest in the Holocaust, start asking questions, and when they hit roadblocks, they become suspicious. Censoring certain claims about the Holocaust will only push them further into "conspiracy theory" territory. Sure maybe some people have ideological reasons to deny it, but I don't think you can generalize that to everybody.
- ahiknsr 5y ago> To me it is rather the demand that certain beliefs may not be questioned that enables things like fascists rising to power Holocaust is not a belief, it is a historical event that has already happened.
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoSo what exactly is "the Holocaust"? Do you know exactly what happened? I rather think historians are still piercing it together. Also, while as I said I don't have reasons to doubt it, I do think that there is something like "winner's history". I have witnessed it with the wars that happened in my lifetime, when it was possible to glimpse some aspects beyond the portrayal in the mainstream media. So I am careful before I believe anything.
- user-the-name 5y agoPretty amazing that this is what gets downvoted in this site.
- mhoad 5y agoThis entire comment section is maybe the clearest example I have seen in a long time of why so many other industries outside of tech kind of look at the tech scene as a amoralistic dumpster fire. I never used to see the value of trying to include humanities as a part of a tech degree until a few years ago and now I think it can't happen fast enough. So many of the arguments presented here wouldn't pass any kind of a 101 level class.
- mavhc 5y agoAnd forgot it again by 2016
- molbioguy 5y agoViolating their expected privacy, fostering moralistic vigilante justice against them, and creating an environment where they have to fear expressing opinions -- that's "poisoning the well" in a far worse way.
- mcphage 5y ago> Violating their expected privacy They're trying to be secret, that's true. But expectations of privacy are for personal matters, this is posting hostile things and then hoping nobody finds out it's you. I don't think the author necessarily has a reasonable expectation of privacy. > creating an environment where they have to fear expressing opinions The Holocaust was a thing that happened. Pretending it didn't isn't expressing an opinion.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> They're trying to be secret, that's true. But expectations of privacy are for personal matters, this is posting hostile things and then hoping nobody finds out it's you. I don't think the author necessarily has a reasonable expectation of privacy. I disagree with this. I think they did have a reasonable expectation of anonymity, they just didn't do a great job at protecting it. Per the article it seems like Epik accept fake names and cryptocurrency; they could have done that and avoided this mess. I'd expect my registrar to protect my personal address, for example, despite the website being my full name. And for my other domains I absolutely would expect them to protect my identity because I paid for WHOIS protection. And none of them are even remotely controversial. > The Holocaust was a thing that happened. Pretending it didn't isn't expressing an opinion. Also disagree. It's an opinion, but a wrong one that they should face social opprobrium for.
- belltaco 5y agoDo you think a political opinion like 'taxes are too high and should be lowered" is on the same moral footing as misinformation like 'the holocaust did not really happen' ?
- 5y ago
- mavhc 5y agoSo you're saying releasing the names of trolls who doxxed people is not funny?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 5y agoThe parent post seems to be saying that employers firing someone for their disagreeable political actions (at least outside of their workplace) is wrong. Agitating contrary to the majority sociopolitical opinion should not make one unemployable; Firing people for inappropriate or immoral political opinion is not new, USA has already been there with e.g. Hoover's Red scare and the 1980s "Moral majority", but in hindsight it seems quite clear that this approach was wrong at least back in those years when it was targeted by the right wing towards the [USA-]left.
- mavhc 5y agoIt's not a political opinion though, that's the point. No one's firing him for saying that taxes are at the wrong level.
- PeterisP 5y agoI'm not sure about what exactly he's been saying and I don't really care to read that because it's likely to be stupid, but I'd consider even stupid and extreme opinions and suggestions (in both directions!) on public health policy, pandemic solutions, elections, geopolitics, immigration policy, religion, human rights, LGBT rights, workers rights, voting rights, socioeconomic equality, affirmative action, education policy, gun policy, healthcare, reproductive care, etc all as political opinions. Crimes, harassment and libel are another issue, but for that we generally want a legal process to determine the guilt and appropriate punishment; simply firing accused suspects is not a proper response because it's not sufficient if he's guilty and far too much if he's not.
- 5y ago
- krapp 5y agoVoltaire didn't give his life so that being exposed as a racist prick could have negative social consequences!
- marcinzm 5y ago>The "Moral Majority" folks were accused of wanting to be everything the Left has become. You think people somehow inherently differ because of their political beliefs? We're all human and both sides will act roughly the same but for different stated reasons. Then denounce the other side for it before doing it themselves.
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoPeople have different ideals. A lot of people really care about free speech and freedom in general.
- marcinzm 5y agoSure but that's the fun thing, you can support this and believe in free speech. After all, free speech does not mean freedom from consequences to most people. Nor are other people forced to not react to your speech in any way since that would impede other freedoms like freedom of association. And publishing this information is also free speech. You could argue that there should be an expectation of privacy but that's different than freedom of speech or freedom in general.
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoNot freedom of consequences: that is a bit too vague. What if the consequence is that somebody shoots you dead if you say the wrong thing? According to you, they still have free speech? Actually I think some real world dictator was literally making that joke, proclaiming that there is freedom of speech in his country. He just can't guarantee for the outcomes.
- marcinzm 5y agoThen the murderer broke the law and will be prosecuted for that. If the government doesn’t prosecute them as they support the action then there’s no freedom of speech. This is why freedom of speech is generally discussed within the context of the government as the government enforces other laws.
- michaelmcdonald 5y agoThis is going beyond "political purity" as the guy was quite evidently involved in racist behaviors. Racism is not a political "right" or "wrong", it's just straight up wrong. Holocaust denial is another one of those issues that isn't "political" but rather a belief that stems from ignorance and hatred. Firing people for being racist is, in my book, completely acceptable.
- FDSGSG 5y ago>What happens when the popular politics change? Either you're happy with them, or go to war. This isn't really a new problem.
- strken 5y agoIt's been the case for a very long time that a sufficiently offensive political opinion would get you fired if brought to the attention of your boss. I think the difference between "business as usual" and McCarthyism or the current purges is how much more effort people are willing to put in to dig up dirt, and how much less offensive the dirt has to be. That being said, the examples given in the article aren't very sympathetic. Back in 2013, Donglegate[0] was absolutely baffling for me, because I wasn't aware anyone could get fired for an overheard dick joke. Getting fired for running an actual Holocaust denial site seems fine. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5391667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5391667
- ryandrake 5y agoI'd love to know the list of companies actually willing to hire someone who owns web sites like whitesencyclopedia.com, and theholocaustisfake.com.
- davewritescode 5y agoPlease don't turn this into a political purity thing. As far as I'm aware, the only people who've faced consequences are people who have owned and run domain names that are inexcusably terrible. I'm no believer in cancel culture, particularly the aspects that get people punished for things they've posted online as teenagers and young adults. But that's entirely different that running a website for holocaust deniers and racists. An employer has a right to fire someone like that. The right wing of this country has really confused freedom of speech with freedom from consequence. In addition to freedom of speech, the constitution provides for freedom of association, i.e. the right to associate or disassociate with groups or people. The problem is that 15 years ago, most companies and people didn't pay as much attention to social media as they do today.
- rsynnott 5y ago> Sure you do. I mean, I'm not sure what your point is. This is absolutely a key problem that newspapers have; on the one hand, no-one wants a news environment where newspapers just publish press releases, but on the other hand most people don't want a repeat of the News of the World scandal either. Newspapers have to tread a fine ethical line on just how involuntarily disclosed information can or should be used. Clearly, an environment where newspapers _never_ reported on leaks or hacks would be a problem; realistically they'd just be press release services at that point. On the other hand, an environment where newspapers uncritically published every leak and hack would _also_ be a problem; this would cause a lot of problems and would, frankly, be such a huge volume of information that it would be useless. They _have_ to editorialise.
- h2odragon 5y agoThis better illustrates my point there: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/new-proof-emerges-of-the-biden-family https://greenwald.substack.com/p/new-proof-emerges-of-the-bi...