3 ms·
Playing brain training games regularly doesn’t boost brainpower
- Tarsul 5y agoI mean we've seen these type of studies/results before so at first I thought this is not surprising. However, they say they let both groups (those who use brain training games and those who don't) basically play brain training games: "They faced Simon-like memory exercises, such spatial reasoning tasks as mentally rotating objects, pattern-finding puzzles and strategy challenges." And even there, there was no real benefit for the brain gamers. My follow-up question would be: What kind of mental stimulation also doesn't help people? E.g. How can we make people smarter (for instance, regarding thinking for oneself and not believing bullshit)? It appears it's very difficult. As if people revert back to themselves whenever the game(/lesson) stops.
- vanderZwan 5y agoThe best candidate seems to be Dual-N-back style training for pushing your working memory, and even that isn't without controversy.
- Fezzik 5y agoLearning logical fallacies could be a good place to start. Thinking about why fallacies are fallacious generally helps strengthen your ability to weed out unsupported conclusions and reshapes how you both assess ideas and present them.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoI think the cultural background of a guy is what make people smarter or to believe bullshit. Not a test or a game but the previous life/culture.
- lupire 5y agoGetting critical thinking training (or not) is part of life/culture.
- nonameiguess 5y agoMaybe they're not being marketed this way, but I was under the impression the benefit possibly offered by brain games like this is slowing cognitive decline in old age, not making otherwise healthy people smarter.
- kiba 5y agoIf that were the case, you would see some difference in the performance metric on tests.
- lupire 5y agoThis study only looked at people playing for up to 18months, and not focused on elderly, not the years you'd need to prevent cognitive decline. Also, not a randomized controlled study, so didn't check for confounding factors like non--brain-gamers engaging in other thinking activities. And apparently didn't check for how much time was spent per day on brain games or other thinking activities. Also, pet peeve, article ends with the researcher exposing her anti-braingame bias and making uninformed speculation unrelated to the study, presenting it as fact.
- BizarroLand 5y agoCalling them Brain Games is just a way to allow people who wouldn't otherwise play games to play them. It's a convenient excuse, and it's alright if that is what people need to allow themselves to have a little fun from time to time.