3 ms·
> Let us please dispense with the moral ambiguity of our view of the Soviet Union. We're talking past each other. I'm talking about the *birth* of the Soviet
by oblio 5y ago
> Let us please dispense with the moral ambiguity of our view of the Soviet Union.
We're talking past each other. I'm talking about the *birth* of the Soviet Union.
Imperial Russia, no matter what you may think of its morals, was an ally of the Western powers. It fought together with them, it was completely exhausted by the war, it collapsed. Immediately after its collapse, the Western powers, acting very much like hyenas (US, UK, France, Japan, etc), invaded their former ally.
The new Russian factions fought each other and fought off the invaders.
How do you look internal politics look in a country in such a situation? Do you think moderates have any chance? When your former allies are betraying you, your country was ravaged by war and is now in a civil war?
The hypothesis was that we will never know for sure if Russia wouldn't have gotten a more moderate socialist government without foreign invasion. It's an "what if" scenario.
- jollybean 5y agoYes, Imperial Russia was definitely a different thing altogether. But it's a stretch to say that those countries 'invaded' Russia. There was 'backing' of a side during a revolution, that's not the same thing. The American revolution was supported by France and the American civil war had 'backing' by other parties. I don't think the backing of outside powers is hugely relevant to that outcome, that said, the point in general (i.e. actual outside invaders) is reasonable. I think it's different in every situation though. I mean Afghanistan, Chile, Cuba, Libya ... all so different there's hardly a common thread other than '2 sides during the Cold War'.