3 ms·
As a musician what happens when you don't think and just do is often superior than when you are mindful of every tiny detail of your hands movement (it can even
by atoav 5y ago
As a musician what happens when you don't think and just do is often superior than when you are mindful of every tiny detail of your hands movement (it can even happen that you are downright unable to play if you are too aware of what you are doing).
This kind of focus is important when practising, but on stage it should just be there with the sound, not sure whether this would be called mindful or the opposite.
Mindfulness is very subjective as well — I know people who are proud of their own mindfulness and I can't help but notice that there are always aspects within their behaviour or their surroundings that they are totally not getting. You get the feeling they want to be so "in tune with themselves" they don't notice what is going on in the person opposite, or in their general surroundings. Maybe they got mindfulness wrong or maybe I got mindfulness wrong, but for me what I see there is the polar opposite of the flow state I described with music
- whynaut 5y agoflow state and mindfulness aren’t really opposed. In fact, having a good grasp of mindfulness allows you to shut down distractions to your own flow as they appear in your mind. Sounds like they got it wrong.
- agumonkey 5y agoI believe western school of music is too much on the analytical side of this. Indian music a bit too. While other cultures are more on plugging into "feel" and letting things emerge/flow.
- atoav 5y agoI am a improvisational musician for a reason.