4 ms·
I haven't had reliability problems, but I do find it annoying that if I don't update my app frequently enough, they just cut communications entirely. That is, I
by gnicholas 5y ago
I haven't had reliability problems, but I do find it annoying that if I don't update my app frequently enough, they just cut communications entirely. That is, I don't get notifications that I've received new messages anymore. I usually find out about this when someone emails me to say they've sent me a message on Signal, but I've not responded.
Instead of silently failing, I wish they would pop up a notification that says "Your version of Signal is now out-of-date, and you will not receive new messages until you update."
- abandonliberty 5y agoI can't imagine this is an intentional choice by Signal. Always assumed it had something to do with the OS silencing unused applications.
- Moru 5y agoYes, this was my impression too. When I turned that off, it started working ok. But this does not help on relatives phones, only on mine.
- gnicholas 5y agoI receive notifications for apps that I use less than this, like Lyft. I manage my notifications very carefully, and I have never silenced Signal on my phone. Also, I don't go that long between sessions of using Signal — just apparently long enough to trigger this issue.
- Vinnl 5y agoFor others with similar problems, they have a troubleshooting guide including model-specific tips at https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007318711-Troubleshooting-Notifications https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007318711-Tr...
- hulitu 5y agoWhatsapp forces you to update to be able to use it further. Not a nice thing.
- gnicholas 5y agoReally? I go years between sessions of Whatsapp and can still get notifications. I wouldn't mind if a messaging app forced me to update to send a new message, or even to view a message that has just been received (though that would be a little lousy if it meant updating over cellular). My issue is that Signal fails silently.
- lnl 5y agoSometimes it's necessary, when the protocol itself is updated, e.g. the multi-device beta page currently says "Messaging or calling someone who is using a very old version of WhatsApp on their phone won't work from your linked device."[1] for this reason. If they don't force those users to upgrade at some point, it would lead to an undesirable situation where you are not guaranteed to be able to message someone from desktop. My experience with my grandmother's phone confirms gnicholas's account that they do this very rarely. But, more importantly for gnicholas's point, Whatsapp gives you a warning days/weeks ahead about the need to update the app. My grandmother is almost never connected to a Wi-Fi network, so her apps don't usually update, and she hardly uses any app other than Whatsapp anyway. She got the warning one time and gave me a call immediately, so I walked her through about what to do (i.e. yes grandma, click the update button). If it silently fails, like gnicholas says, and if this happens often, then I can't imagine using Signal with her. [1]: https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/download-and-installation/about-multi-device-beta https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/download-and-installation/a...
- krater23 5y agoYes, they do, but Signal does this too. But on Whatsapp they give you a month, on Signal some days. BTW, I got messages from both that I have to update. No silent failing at all.
- krater23 5y agoOn my Signal client a message like this happened relatively often and gave me only some days to update.