5 ms·
Nokia confirms N9 MeeGo phone not coming to US
- Luyt 15y agoIn the meantime, ESR on his continuing 'Smartphone Wars'[1] saga: "...With Nokia and RIM in collapse and Microsoft failing to gain traction, the smartphone market is increasingly just a two-horse race – Android va. Apple... ...in a survey of usage in 56 countries, Android has reached 48% market share worldwide. Then the comScore figures on US installed base up to June 2011 came out, and report only 40% share here... ...Google is buying patents from IBM, doubtless with the intention of turning the confrontations with Sun and Apple into Mexican standoffs. My evaluation continues to be that the smartphone patent wars will be like a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury but in the end signifying nothing." [1] http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=3548 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=3548
- zbowling 15y agoI'm annoyed by Nokia's failure with MeeGo. The reasons it gave as to why the new management wasn't behind MeeGo were nothing more than excuses. They got that Microsoft's plant in there now. Their board is completely shortsighted when it comes to seeing the long term value it could have for Nokia. Nokia is abandoning it and has nothing in their portfolio of real value except some patents and IP.
- boyter 15y agoNothing but patents and IP worked pretty well for IBM while getting their act together.
- rbanffy 15y agoMy bet is that Microsoft will "save" Nokia a couple years from now and use its remaining patents to extort every phone maker.
- michaelcampbell 15y ago"Embrace, exterminate, litigate"?
- rbanffy 15y agoPossible. The Nokia patent portfolio in the hands of an NPE partly funded by Microsoft would be able to do a whole lot of very selective damage.
- trezor 15y agoIf you are going to predict any major actor right now of aggressively and offensively suing people into oblivion, Apple would be the obvious target of that accusation and not Microsoft. Microsoft has enough business vested all over the place. They don't need mobile to profit. Apple's only real source of income however, is now reduced to iOS-devices only. They need mobile, desperately. The fact that Apple is already suing left and right, right now, when their platform is going well and they technically shouldn't need to be in any state of despair, that should tell you who to fear the most.
- rbanffy 15y agoOh. Apple will litigate aggressively, of course. But Nokia is clearly moving towards becoming either a target for acquisition as a whole or, after dismemberment, its patent portfolio is. Microsoft won't do it openly, however. It's more likely they'll employ proxies for that, not unlike the way they funded SCO's campaign. Besides, we are talking about Nokia's current relationship with Microsoft, not Apple. Don't you think it's a bit suspicious a recently hired CEO who was until recently a high profile Microsoft employee discontinues a major platform investment on the eve of launching a competitive product (I have played with the N9 and it's a very good phone) and bets the company on a yet-unproven (and I am being more than generous on this assessment) Microsoft product?
- trezor 15y agoDon't you think it's a bit suspicious a recently hired CEO who was until recently a high profile Microsoft employee discontinues a major platform investment on the eve of launching a competitive product (I have played with the N9 and it's a very good phone) and bets the company on a yet-unproven (and I am being more than generous on this assessment) Microsoft product? I haven't tried the N9 so I cannot comment on it nor the platform which powered it, only that historically, Nokia's only edge has been good hardware. They have been (and still are, as far as I have seen) absolutely horrible at software. I would trust a platform made by Microsoft infinitely more than anything coming out of Nokia HQ, and that is despite all the failings of Microsoft in the mobile and tablet space. Now... With that said: There is no doubt that by going the Microsoft route Nokia is losing something. They are now a generic phone-vendor delivering someone else's OS. They no longer fully own their own platform and stack. This is quite a significant loss and definitely a big risk. However: Given Nokia's history with delivering software and software-platforms, I think it's a smaller risk than trying (once again) to deliver something made in-house. And I really don't find it "suspicious" that a recently hired CEO choose to turn to technology and people he already know. I find it a very obvious move, even though it's not very obvious if it is the best choice or not.
- nvictor 15y agowho woulda thunk? ;)
- pimeys 15y agoI'm so angry for Nokia's decision. N9 was the first phone in several years which made me excited and proud of what Nokia's done. And now they dump it. For Windows Phone. Great.
- rvschuilenburg 15y agoI was really excited about the N900 too. Not that i have anything against it now, but it's just sad to know nokia has just abandoned the platform right after releasing the phone. Community support is great though!
- gcb 15y agon9 was ok. and even then, years late.
- nodata 15y agoA good way of creating demand is to deny something. Perhaps that's their strategy.
- michaelcampbell 15y agoIt works pretty well for game consoles.
- anonymoushn 15y agoThis doesn't prevent you from using it. I will be importing mine as soon as it launches.
- gareim 15y agoThe N9 isn't being released because Elop wants his WP7 phones to win in America and the N9 would just be some strong competition. Especially since the WP7 phone they have planned looks just like an N9. Here's the line taken from Engadget's page that pretty much proves it in my mind. "Decisions are based on an assessment of existing and upcoming products that make up Nokia's extensive product portfolio and the best way in which to address local market opportunities." The word "upcoming" just keeps popping out at me.
- pavlov 15y agoThe N9 in the US never had a chance because the carriers don't want it. I have a hard time believing it would be "strong competition" for anything at $600 unlocked. Nokia is going Windows-only in America because that's the only way they can get the carriers to go along. It's that simple.
- cookiecaper 15y agoI'm not convinced of this at all. Can you provide some additional justification? You just think that carriers won't want to support another new platform?
- pavlov 15y agoWhy do you think they'd want to support another new and incompatible platform? What can MeeGo offer to AT&T or Verizon? Both Nokia and Palm/HP have had a very difficult time getting the US carriers to distribute and subsidize their smartphones. They had no interest in adding MeeGo to the lineup, regardless of Elop's decision. The carriers already know Windows Phone and they have a relationship with Microsoft. Nokia has reportedly committed some serious money for marketing their WP devices in the US. The combined resources of Microsoft and Nokia has certainly got some carriers interested.
- mikecane 15y ago>>>What can MeeGo offer to AT&T or Verizon? Customers who'd want an N9 over all other phones. Why should there be only three slots for people: iOs, Android, Windows Phone (haha, on that third one). Since when is telling people what they CAN'T have good business? Where's the free in the free market?
- yason 15y agoThey really work hard to cut off all excitement and upcoming income. Even in Europe they announced that N9 will be the first and last MeeGo phone: who would like to buy something that's cut off future support already at the time of sale? I still don't believe this is just a coincidence. I know stupidity is generally rampant but Nokia has become the universe's giant sinkhole of stupidity within the last year or two that it can't have happened but on purpose.
- markokocic 15y agoI don't know why Finnish govt doesn't start some investigation on possible criminal activities in Nokia management. I don't say that someone tries to bury Nokia on purpose, but their moves are suspicious enough to warrant at least an investigation. If Nokia continue this way, Finnish economy is going to suffer, a lot.
- forgotAgain 15y agoThis should have been obvious. Microsoft wouldn't want the Nokia Windows Phone message to be diluted by MeeGo. The N9 was just meant as a sop to developers rather than completely cutting the developers off at the knees. That would have killed any chance for them to move to WP apps.