7 ms·
The entire situation is a shitshow. I know multiple families who immigrated to the US on H-1B for tech jobs 20 years ago but are still waiting for residency. Gr
by paxys 5y ago
The entire situation is a shitshow. I know multiple families who immigrated to the US on H-1B for tech jobs 20 years ago but are still waiting for residency. Green cards are legally available but USCIS just won't process their applications, citing lack of resources. Now as their kids – who were as young as one year old when they came here – turn 21 they are being deported to their "home country", that they have zero connection with.
There is no DACA/DREAM equivalent for these people even though they did everything 100% legally and have greatly contributed to the US economy. There are estimated to be >960,000 people currently stuck in this limbo, mostly Asian and mostly in tech (https://www.fwd.us/news/per-country-cap-reform-priority-bill-spotlight/ https://www.fwd.us/news/per-country-cap-reform-priority-bill...).
- andi999 5y agoHere you could sue them to process the application; is this not viable in the US?
- ashtonkem 5y agoGenerally no. The US has relatively tight rules on when and why you can sue them.
- sharmajai 5y agoThat's being tried [1]. Although, it's not going well [2]. [1] https://www.visalaw.com/onboarding-mass-litigation-clients/ https://www.visalaw.com/onboarding-mass-litigation-clients/ [2] https://twitter.com/LilySAxelrod/status/1437846756394520582 https://twitter.com/LilySAxelrod/status/1437846756394520582
- throwdecro 5y agoYeah, it's really unconscientious to have a system where the stakes are so high behave so unpredictably. People make important decisions based on how things are supposed to work. Whatever the "correct" parameters for immigration are, the system really should behave predictably.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dudul 5y agoIsn't an H1B only renewable once for a total of 6 years? Maybe it has changed but I think it was like that when I had one ~12 years ago.
- VictorPath 5y ago> immigrated to the US on H-1B for tech jobs 20 years ago They didn't immigrate, they came on a 3-6 year work visa and chose to get 3 year extensions. I wouldn't choose to settle in a country if all I had was a 3 year work visa. They're not "in limbo", they're people working on 3 year work visas. If they're unhappy they're free to move back to Bangalore or wherever they came from. I have no problem with making life easier on them like allowing someone on a 3 year H1B visa switch companies without penalty, but you're trying to stretch a law allowing 3 years of work for workers we supposedly can not find in the US into a promise of a green card, and it is not. If what you're saying is the case, the H1B laws would have never passed. An inch was promised and you act as if it was a promise for a mile.
- whoisburbansky 5y agoThe promised inch is effectively a mile for anyone born anywhere but “Bangalore” as you say, so why the griping?
- m_ke 5y agoHow else do you expect people to immigrate here if not on a visa?
- VictorPath 5y agoPeople don't immigrate on a visa. You immigrate when you have a green card or citizenship. Someone on a 6 month tourist visa or 3 year H1B employment visa hasn't immigrated, they are on a visa allowing them in the US for that time period.
- paxys 5y agoYou didn't answer the question though. What is the "ideal" way to immigrate to the US according to you?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Consultant32452 5y agoWe are in a 4th and 5th generation hot war with China. They are killing tens of thousands of our citizens by not stopping the illegal fentanyl trade even after we pointed them to the guy running it. The government has had a few high profile arrests of academics not claiming their Chinese income which they are required to do for national security reasons. There will be more squeezes on Asian people in the coming years and no one will really say why directly. This is not an endorsement of any particular policy, but an explanation.
- pbaka 5y agoYeah, if only somebody arrested the Purdue pharma owners... Oh wait, not those culprits, scratch that, those people with a DOJ deal... You mean the other ones from the other side of the Pacific... gotcha...
- rayiner 5y agoThis is a terrible situation. As the kid of an H1-B I can’t imagine being in that predicament. At the same time, this is what happens when the basis of your immigration system is “legislation by hostage taking.” Ever wonder why the H1B says “temporary” status on paper, and you have to pretend like you plan to go back home at some point? (“Dual intent?”) That’s because it’s because it was never designed to be a permanent immigration system. No permanent immigration system designed for that purpose would let you build your life in the country first and then decide only a decade later whether you’ll be allowed to stay. It’s absurd. Since the 1960s the executive branch has been doing with fragile regulation or executive action things that it can’t achieve consensus to do through Congress. The 1990s reforms that created the H1B did nothing more than paper over the most egregious shortcomings of using a temporary worker visa as the main vehicle for permanent immigration. DACA is a prime example of what happens when your political system is so broken that you have to use executive action because you can’t get concensus in Congress. And it shows how fragile that can be. Folks considering immigrating to America should understand: H1B is not meant for permanent immigration. Proceed at your own risk. Maybe try the more sensible immigration regimes in Australia or Canada.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- laurencerowe 5y ago> Ever wonder why the H1B says “temporary” status on paper, and you have to pretend like you plan to go back home at some point? (“Dual intent?”) As I understand it the "dual intent" means you don't have to pretend you plan to go back home at some point. After I switched to an O-1 from an H-1B for a new job I was advised not to leave the country while my green card application was in progress because applying for a green card could potentially be grounds for denying entry at the border on a visa like the O-1 without the dual intent.
- dilyevsky 5y agoYes h1b dual intent means you dont have to prove ties to homeland and such as was explained to me by my company’s lawyer a while ago
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThis is even more sad when contrasted with the illegal immigration crisis at the southern border. We are rewarding criminal entry into the country and punishing lawful citizen candidates. Welcome to the era of inverted incentives!
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This is even more sad when contrasted with the illegal immigration crisis at the southern border. There's no illegal immigration crisis at the southern border. There are occasional refugee crises and most critically a mistreatment crisis (the latter exacerbated by the people that have, for political purposes, also invented the myth of an illegal immigration crisis), but actual illegal immigration has been low, not a crisis, for some time. > We are rewarding criminal entry into the country Uh, no, there are lots of things you can make colorable arguments about about no-visa entry on the southern border, but that it is being rewarded right now is not one of them.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThis argument is dishonest or misguided. [1] Illegal immigration is real. There is a [2] crisis at the southern border. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_immigration https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_immigration [2] https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/09/24/politics/biden-harris-texas-migrants/index.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/09/24/poli...
- baybal2 5y agoWe live in strange times. There used to be a time when kingdoms would raid each other for new subjects, now the opposite is in effect.
- llampx 5y agoWhy raid other kingdoms for their most productive subjects, when you can use your economic and cultural might to make them want to come and work for you?
- mithusingh32 5y ago"lack of resources" is utter BS. My wife got her green card in less than a year after we got married. And she came to the USA on a fiance visa.
- emptyparadise 5y agoWhere did she come from?
- mithusingh32 5y agoIndia. We applied for her green card during peak covid.
- nsonha 5y ago> their "home country", that they have zero connection with. This has never been my concern as an immigrant because we just assume we won't have any connection, in any country, from the moment we leave our home. I think going back is more of a problem with a way of life we are not (no longer) familiar with, culturally and politically
- ikerdanzel 5y agoIn America being illegals pays. The entire America is based on the concept of "risking it and if it is illegals it is even bettet - rule of laws my ass".