4 ms·
America has a small population relative to China, India, and the whole EU. America has giant tech and science industries and needs lots of workers to remain co
by echelon 5y ago
America has a small population relative to China, India, and the whole EU.
America has giant tech and science industries and needs lots of workers to remain competitive.
We're feeding these industries with lots of talent that is born here, but raising children has become increasingly complicated with the eroding middle class and desire to have fewer babies.
Parents don't have support. It's not a fun or rewarding job, especially in a world where you can turn Netflix or TikTok on for a quick dopamine hit and plan on being childless.
We can fill this need with immigration. We don't need less of it, we need more. These positions will be filled anyway, and if it happens abroad that will lower American competitiveness. Not bad for the world. Just stating this from America's perspective.
But you also pointed to a problem that we should address domestically: making child rearing easier and desirable. We could provide assistance (time off, early childhood caregiving) and tax incentives.
I also think a pragmatic, though inequitable, approach to developmental incentives would help. Tax breaks for parents or "fun money" for children who are involved in extracurriculars: STEM, music/arts, clubs, "leadership", etc.
Kids would love to earn a salary to buy toys and games. Pay them a small stipend to follow an academic or artistic interest. Or be involved in a club of some kind. It doesn't have to be much of a monetary reward: $50/month or even less. It won't matter for rich kids, but will make a world of difference for the underprivileged.
- syshum 5y ago>>We're feeding these industries with lots of talent that is born here Are we though? I am not seeing it. The education system, even universities are still often behind the times, and getting a CS degree or CIT degree is not going to help you much in a modern company (or even a legacy company) the skills gap for recent graduates is huge, though personally I am somewhat glad for this because we need to get away from the system of credentials, at least university credentials.
- Grakel 5y agoI agree with a lot of your points, but I think a good education system would be able to train huge amounts of Americans to do whatever work was needed. Along with the parenting incentives you mention. We don't need more immigrants, we don't need a much larger population. There's a lot of room in this country, and that's a good thing. Some people want to densify everything.
- ryan93 5y agoYou cant train huge amounts of people to do serious intellectual work you have to be born with that ability. Most people born that way arent american since most people arent american
- Grakel 5y agoYet in America there are vast numbers of smart people getting left behind educationally.
- ryan93 5y agoNot enough to even remotely match the high IQ immigration from dozens of other countries with combined populations 10x the US
- Grakel 5y agoCool maybe they can stay there and solve things like hunger and water access instead of helping figure out ways to squeeze another advertising dollar.
- neartheplain 5y ago>but raising children has become increasingly complicated with the eroding middle class and desire to have fewer babies. False premise. Lots of Americans want to have kids, they just can't afford it [0]. This reality hits immigrant families too. Unless housing, childcare, healthcare, and higher education are once again made affordable to the middle class, mass immigation is and will remain an economic Ponzi scheme. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/05/upshot/americans-are-having-fewer-babies-they-told-us-why.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/05/upshot/americans-are-havi...