2 ms·
Lodsys did not patent this. At best, Intellectual Ventures patented it, and Lodsys "bought" the patents, probably through some more nefarious means, with the so
by jrockway 15y ago
Lodsys did not patent this. At best, Intellectual Ventures patented it, and Lodsys "bought" the patents, probably through some more nefarious means, with the sole intent of profiting through litigation. No innovation there.
I see this on some level, but on some other level, it makes sense to be able to transfer property. You invented something. The government gave you exclusive rights to sue anyone who did anything remotely resembling what you invented. You decided the best way to profit from your invention was to sell this right to someone else.
Clearly, this is fine. The problem is not that you cashed out on your work. The problem is that the government shouldn't have given you the right to sue other people for doing something similar to what you do.
We can't blame Lodsys for exploiting the holes in the patent system. For that, we have to blame the system itself.
The right way to monetize innovative software-related ideas is to write innovative software, which is protected by copyright. But the law says differently -- just coming up with an idea is more valuable than coming up with a product that uses that idea to be innovative. And there's your problem.
- nitrogen 15y agoWe can't blame Lodsys for exploiting the holes in the patent system. For that, we have to blame the system itself. Yes, we can. We can blame Lodsys, IV, et. al. for behaving legally but unethically and/or counterproductively to society, while also blaming the system itself. Otherwise, this statement is roughly similar to saying that you can't blame bullies for beating up nerds; it's the nerds' fault for being weak, and the playground's fault for not having nerd protection.
- pyre 15y ago> We can't blame Lodsys for exploiting the holes in > the patent system. For that, we have to blame the > system itself. Translation: > So long as something is legal, it is moral. Or: > We can't blame that serial murder just because > he found a way to kill people that is perfectly > legal!
- alnayyir 15y agoYour moral framework is questionable at best.