2 ms·
You have it backwards: why should we permit people to claim ownership of ideas at all? We arguably have a natural right to mimic what we see others do, or apply
by naasking 5y ago
You have it backwards: why should we permit people to claim ownership of ideas at all? We arguably have a natural right to mimic what we see others do, or apply the ideas that other teach us, or retell the stories that others told us. What a backwards world we live in where we have to justify exercising our natural rights.
- omginternets 5y ago>You have it backwards: why should we permit people to claim ownership of ideas at all? I don't think that's fair. I'm responding to a claim that IP is "wrong". The parent poster purported to demonstrate why this is so, and had not done this. The burden of proof is not on me.
- naasking 5y agoSince you agreed with the OP that IP is no longer achieving it's stated goals, then the original reasons justifying the restrictions of our natural rights no longer hold and thus our natural rights take precedence. The burden for establishing continued restrictions is clear. You spoke of principles, but I think you got them backwards, and thus sought to clarify what the actual underlying principles are.