4 ms·
> The issue is that when people reply to my tweets, they are trying to use my audience to push their message. If they have their own followers, OK: that's them
by xg15 5y ago
> The issue is that when people reply to my tweets, they are trying to use my audience to push their message. If they have their own followers, OK: that's them talking to their people. But they want to talk to my audience.
Your premise here is "I should be able to completely control the conversation that reaches my audience from my tweets".
I personally can't agree with this premise at all - and my suspicion is that a lot of issues with Twitter arise because the service itself is still figuring out whether or not it should adopt this as a goal or a non-goal.
The problem I see with the premise is that it leads to echo-chambers in which only the arguments permitted initial author are visible.
I don't mean we should permit abuse or brigarding, but basic criticism or counter-arguments to a tweet must be permitted. This is especially important for me as a follower, because it allows me to put a tweet into proper context.
I fear that full curation of replies could be abused by all parts of the political spectrum and also by completely unpolitical scammers: Political pundits could limit replies to enthusiastic agreement, MLM scammers to gleaming success stories, promoters of questionable cryptocurrencies could hide uncomfortable questions, etc.
- saurik 5y agoI have no issue with any of these worst-case scenarios you mention because 1) these were people who opted-in to listen to these people (who might also have biased websites: "big whoop") and 2) I maintain, as I argue in more detail in my other response to someone else, that the current situation is worse for biased censorship of the platform as a whole because it implies that we are going to decide what is "abuse or brigading" as part of some centralized filter, with the result that some people are just going to either lose access to the platform entirely--even to talk to their own audience--and/or certain subjects are going to become verboten due to some disagreement with the zeitgeist. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28661600 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28661600 We need to stop building centralized filters and instead push all of the moderation to the edges--even when I admit it maybe feels awkward at first glance--as it is what eventually ensures that we all have a right to communicate. You get to decide what is talked about in your Telegram channel, WhatsApp group, or (yes) Twitter sub-thread so that I have the right to decide what is talked about in mine... lest we both lose the ability to decide such after passing it off to some centralized "offensive speech" filter that ends up deciding all photos of nipples, talk of non-normative sexuality, discussion of COVID-19, or information about the latest Russian election are off-limits, because you simply can't build a centralized system for moderation without marching straight into a dystopia. https://youtu.be/vsazo-Gs7ms https://youtu.be/vsazo-Gs7ms