3 ms·
FSD beta has had no known accidents at all, though. The argument above was presuming that measurement and statistics can show whether a system is "safe" or not
by ajross 5y ago
FSD beta has had no known accidents at all, though. The argument above was presuming that measurement and statistics can show whether a system is "safe" or not. If you refuse to accept that as an axiom I don't know how to reply.
The question in the linked article we're discussing isn't whether Tesla FSD is "finished" as a product, or perfect, or whatever. It's simply whether or not we should allow it to be tested in a wide beta on public roads.
And where's the evidence that we shouldn't?
- justinpombrio 5y ago> FSD beta has had no known accidents at all, though. Do you have a source on Tesla FSD? I don't know much about it. The basic info we'd need is number of fatalities, number of miles driven, and to check that these numbers mean roughly the right thing.
- ajross 5y agoYou want a source on the absence of evidence? I don't have that. No one has reported an accident to a FSD beta car anywhere I am aware of. The source is me.
- justinpombrio 5y agoYou are a fine source! So fatalities = 0. Any idea about miles driven, by Tesla FSD beta cars? Or is there no public info on that? If it was human drivers (in the US), you'd expect a fatality by around the 70 million mile mark. And fatalities caused by self-driving cars are very newsworthy, so you'd hear about it.