6 ms·
> Logic is the science of the possible. As such, it is at the root of all other sciences, all of which are sciences of the actual, i.e. that which really exists
by roenxi 5y ago
> Logic is the science of the possible. As such, it is at the root of all other sciences, all of which are sciences of the actual, i.e. that which really exists.
Not the focus of the article, but a good view of logic is that it is the art of consistency. A powerful, single-purpose tool to tell its user if they hold mutually inconsistent beliefs. I can believe that the sky is blue, the sky is green and that the sky is exactly one colour - but if I use logic I can detect that something in my worldview is woefully broken.
- boris_m 5y agoAlso a good formulation. It's amazing how little has been written on the subject (of what logic is.)
- pfortuny 5y agoWell, Aristotle’s studies on logic are called the “organon” (meaning “tool”) exactly because of that.
- bmitc 5y ago> It's amazing how little has been written on the subject (of what logic is.) I’m not sure that’s the case. Just searching “philosophy of logic” yields oodles of resources. It’s an entire field of study.
- boris_m 5y agoI meant at a higher lever.
- bmitc 5y agoI'm not really sure what you mean by higher level, but I'm still not sure that's the case if one is assuming you mean works that are more introductory in nature. For example, from the introduction in the first chapter, titled "Consistency", in Wilfred Hodge's Logic: > Logic can be defined as the study of consistent sets of beliefs; this will be our starting-point. Some people prefer to define logic as the study of valid arguments. Between them and us there is no real disagreement, as section 11 will show. But consistency makes an easier beginning. > Logic is about consistency – but not about all types of consistency. ... > The type of consistency which concerns logicians is not loyalty or justice or sincerity; it is compatibility of beliefs. A set of beliefs is consistent if the beliefs are compatible with each other. To give a slightly more precise definition, which will guide us through the rest of this book: a set of beliefs is called consistent if these beliefs could all be true together in some possible situation. The set of beliefs is called inconsistent if there is no possible situation in which all the beliefs are true. Note that this is identical to the parent comment, and this book is originally from the 1970s.
- boris_m 5y agoBy higher level, I mean big picture. Not necessarily introductory, but ones that don't employ logical concepts such as "proof", "formal" etc, because you cannot define a field of study using concepts from that field. This example is good, but not sure what are you trying to say by posting it (I didn't say that noone ever wrote anything on what logic is.)
- drdeca 5y ago> because you cannot define a field of study using concepts from that field. Why not?
- boris_m 5y agoBecause the definition would be circular.
- drdeca 5y agoDoes a field of study have to be defined in order for the concepts in it to be defined? I don’t see why. Can’t you define concepts x,y,z, and then define the field of study as being “about x,y,z and the things related to them”? I’m guessing you mean something different by “defining a field of study” (different from my default/initial interpretation of the phrase I mean), but I’m not sure what else you mean by it.
- guerrilla 5y agoVery much has been written at a higher level. There are thousands of advanceds books and dozens of specialized journals.
- travisgriggs 5y agoIt is the set of all things not found under the category of illogical.
- appleflaxen 5y agoGreat formulation. One could also say that logic is the study of what is not disproven.
- Reflecticon 5y agoHow would you do that?
- IncRnd 5y agoThe assumption in what you wrote is that logic is Boolean, which is not always the case. There are other logics.
- rini17 5y agoOther logics need to have their own consistency rules too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 5y agoI don't think that logic is at the root of most sciences, if at all. The statistical tools which science employs may have logical underpinnings, but the theories formed by science aren't axiomatic. For example, there is hardly any enthusiasm for axiomatizing physics by either mathematicians or physicists. Science is also very comfortable with holding competing theories, whereas in conventional logic that would be "explosively" destructive.
- boris_m 5y agoNot necessarily, you have competing theories based on the same kind of logic - it is just that every theory would be based on different set of postulates and will reside in a different logical space (i.e. a different category). But the fact that that two theories don't agree with each other does not mean that one of them is illogical. Actually, I'd argue that they have to both be logical in order not to agree with each other at all i.e. logic is the common ground which enables you to express the differences. Also, I do think that physics is pretty axiomatic right from it's roots. Newton's main inspiration for forming his theory is the work of Euclid, i.e. first formal system that was ever created.
- threatofrain 5y agoFor science, competing theories exist within the same universe of discourse. That's because scientific theories find their basis in their ability to generate new or better predictions from existing empiricism. And in terms of modern physics, I reiterate that there is no enthusiasm from either mathematicians or physicists to axiomatize physics.
- boris_m 5y agoThere is some: https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0101012 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0101012 And according to the first sentence of the summary the current formulation is axiomatic as well...
- roenxi 5y agoScience can't be logically inconsistent. If a system is logically inconsistent then you can prove anything from it, so there would be nothing for science to explain - everything would follow from the inconsistency. Science is comfortable with uncertainty, but not with things that are illogical. It has to be logical, and the scientists have to accept some sort of logic to give theories a better-worse hierarchy.