3 ms·
I agree with the sibling comment by Nevermark: the scientific method isn't easy to understand at all, partly because nobody has a consistent definition of what
by mike_hearn 5y ago
I agree with the sibling comment by Nevermark: the scientific method isn't easy to understand at all, partly because nobody has a consistent definition of what it is. Your own comment illustrates the difficulty. You say the scientific method is easy to understand and then start talking about experiments.
Experiments? Is that actually a required part of the scientific method? Apparently not: lots of fields presented as scientific to the public can't do experiments. Most obviously, neither climatology, epidemiology nor economics do experiments, despite being fields with enormous direct impact on governments and therefore people's lives. You can try to refine it to "making testable predictions" but then it would require that the predictions are actually tested - real scientific papers often make predictions without testing them against reality.
What about computer science? Is it really a science? Most people would say the scientific method is a way to discover knowledge about the natural world, but there's nothing natural about computers. I myself am not convinced computer science is a science, but, it's treated as one by the institutions.
The prevalence of papers that simply present unvalidated statistical/algebraic models raises huge questions about what science is in theory vs what it is in practice. In theory, science is about discovering knowledge about the natural world, by refining hypotheses which make testable predictions into validated theories. In practice science is whatever granting agencies, universities and journals find interesting. Nothing anywhere in the so-called scientific system actually tests that the work is following the scientific method, nor is there even a working definition of what that would mean. The result is that scientific journals routinely publish pseudo-scientific claims without realizing that it's what they're doing (see my other comment).
In fact many fields are almost entirely a-theoretical: social psychology papers like the one this thread is about aren't rooted in an attempt to refine a grand unified theory of the mind. They're just testing academic folk intuitions, and are often driven by political or ideological concerns more than an attempt to derive theory.
In such a world, deification of The Scientific Method™ is naive. There is no such method, just a hodgepodge of tactics and social conventions that seems to work better than nothing, but which may or may not be actually used by something labelled as scientific.