3 ms·
Hypothetically speaking, say we just assumed that basically everything the gun rights advocates are predicting is going to come to pass. Does it matter? I'm ma
by roenxi 5y ago
Hypothetically speaking, say we just assumed that basically everything the gun rights advocates are predicting is going to come to pass. Does it matter?
I'm making a guess here that the gun control advocates come in 2 flavours:
1) People who are scared of being shot, and prioritise that fear highly.
2) People who are committed to maintaining the status quo, and don't want there to be even a hypothetical potential for meaningful opposition to the police (such people, though relatively rare, are common in government).
I doubt either of those groups cares about the arguments being made by gun advocates, so I'm not sure what difference it would make if the gun advocates were right about everything.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoSo you self identify two groups and further assume the logical leanings of those groups and thus you have an argument, you think? Wow, dude. This is HN. I'd expect more intelligence. And before you begin typing out a response saying "What have i missed, please correct me". . .this is not a forum for babysitting people. If you're going to comment on a complex topic like Gun Control, you are expected to familiarize yourself with the pro and cons at least by doing a little bit of due diligence in googling around and reading up on the forums representing the two sides. A drive by comment with an authoritative take such as yours should be better informed and constructed with more logic.
- roenxi 5y agoFair enough. So say hypothetically speaking, say we just assumed that basically everything the gun rights advocates are predicting is going to come to pass. Why does it matter?
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoIf you say "fair enough". i'd assume you agree with the need to read and familiarize yourself with the Gun Rights Advocates positions.
- roenxi 5y agoThat is why I've included a question mark. Labouring the point a little bit, the initial post wasn't an argument. It was an (admittedly awkward) longform question with a basic intent of "this is what I'm thinking, it doesn't seem very well thought out, where are the soft spots?". Telling me I'm not intelligent doesn't really give me a lead on what to do next.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoTelling you you're posing a question in an unintelligent way is the first point. The direct reason why is you're making up your own facts and then further adding inference to the groups you've identified. The "next steps" here are to consider if this is the approach that helps answer your question. I suggest it does not. Further, you could consider if you're in a position to have an authoritative take as you've done here without doing the due diligence on the arguments as i've called out. The question mark does nothing to further the debate. It is premised on your expectation for someone else to do your reading assignment for you. Please, do better. Try. Try reading up. Try seeing the arguments on both sides, BEFORE doing drive by comments with such a simplistic and irresponsible of condensing the positions of a serious debate into a "So what?" comment. Hope that helps.
- jacobolus 5y agoGroup 3: People who don’t want to live in a society where violent thugs use murder or threats of murder to impose their will upon their neighbors, and are tired of seeing their compatriots die easily preventable deaths, in numbers vastly exceeding any other developed country.