4 ms·
The day-to-day mundane aspects of "IP" law* do "work fairly well," yes, but their purpose is not to benefit the public, and as it happens, they do not benefit t
by kragen 5y ago
The day-to-day mundane aspects of "IP" law* do "work fairly well," yes, but their purpose is not to benefit the public, and as it happens, they do not benefit the public. There are spectacular cases where they cause great and spectacular damage to the public like those you mention, while in the common day-to-day cases they cause less damage, or in any case subtler damage. Occasionally they provide a public benefit, but in those cases they are malfunctioning, and often such cases get fixed.
Fundamentally, the operation of "intellectual property" is to treat your intellect as someone else's property under the law. By granting economic monopolies to private companies in particular goods, such as the sale of copies of _1984_, the government converts the abundance provided by our modern machinery into artificial scarcity, thus providing those companies with monopoly profits. The rationale given for this is that it provides an incentive to create those goods in the first place, but where economists have analyzed these incentives quantitatively, it invariably results that the monopoly rights currently granted cause enormously more harm to the public than the extra production they propel.
______
* "Intellectual property" is a fairly incoherent group of laws that it rarely makes sense to discuss collectively. Here I mean copyrights, patents, trade secrets, sui generis database protection, and noncompete agreements, rather than trademarks, mask works, and privacy.