6 ms·
SWE first and pilot second. It’s both a little sobering but also very mind-clearing to think that no one outside the airplane is going to bring the airplane saf
by sokoloff 5y ago
SWE first and pilot second. It’s both a little sobering but also very mind-clearing to think that no one outside the airplane is going to bring the airplane safely to its next runway.
I find it interesting that drivers could stand some more of this prioritization. (Texting is communicating; it can wait until the driving is done.)
- imoverclocked 5y agoAgreed. If drivers had to go through 1/10th of the training/certification a private pilot does, our society would look very different.
- JKolios 5y agoWe'd probably have far more investment in public transport, for one.
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoIn New South Wales most learner drivers require 120 hours on the road before they can take the test, far in excess of the 45 hour requirement for private pilots. Here in the UK, we have the Light Aircraft Pilot's Licence, with lower requirements than the ordinary PPL.
- imoverclocked 5y agoThe US also has a light sport aircraft (LSA) category and a sport pilot license with less requirements but more restrictions. While the 40 hours is a minimum, most people require more to complete their PPL training and pass their exam. Some aircraft do not require a pilot license but I’m hard pressed for good reasons to fly without prior training.
- nicbou 5y agoI travel a lot by motorcycle. You can truly see the difference in driver training between countries. It goes from German to murderous. Unsurprisingly, German driving tests are fairly thorough.
- mgdlbp 5y agoInteresting Baader-Meinhof phenomenon here: I went down a Wikipedia rabbit hole just yesterday of aviation accidents involving depressurization and subsequent incapacitation of (virtually) everyone on board. In each of the three cases I read[0], while the aircraft remained airborne for 1-5 hours after losing its pilot(s), other aircraft sent to intercept could only observe in vain as the autopilot proceeded obliviously towards the inevitable: each of the three ran out of fuel before crashing and killing all on board. This had me wondering several things (as a layman), notably: did the use of autopilot make for certain doom in these cases, as possibly an aircraft without might have entered a state of descent allowing its occupants to regain consciousness; and, what avionic solutions could aid in this type of accident, which seems inevitable given the rapid cognitive toll of hypoxia? A vigilance switch for the autopilot to remain engaged (on some aircraft currently but uncommon)? Controlled descent by the autopilot when fuel is depleted? And especially, remote piloting by instruments, which seems invaluable in a variety of related emergencies? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522 and the two linked in '#See also'
- sokoloff 5y agoCirrus has a Hypoxia recognition and recovery system: https://www.avweb.com/air-shows-events/cirrus-adds-hypoxia-recognition/ https://www.avweb.com/air-shows-events/cirrus-adds-hypoxia-r... Absent such a system, the autopilot probably didn't doom the occupants any more than no autopilot would have. It's extraordinarily unlikely that an uncommanded and uncontrolled descent from FL280 or higher (28K feet) would level off at an altitude above the ground but below around 15K feet to allow the crew to recover the airplane. (For one, a wing would probably roll off at some point in the process, leading to a spiral, but even with a wing-leveler, it's not likely the plane would be trimmed to descend and if it did, it would be unlikely to level off above terrain for long enough.)
- United857 5y agoThere are now systems which can find the nearest suitable airport and autoland the plane, for example https://skiesmag.com/features/virtual-co-pilot-garmin-autoland/ https://skiesmag.com/features/virtual-co-pilot-garmin-autola...
- phkahler 5y agoStudent pilot. This part rang so true: >> Pilots know that no one else can help them fly their aircraft in an emergency. My first solo was... interesting. Takeoff was fine. Climbed to about 400ft and then a full on panic attack (2nd time in my life) as I realized the implications of the empty seat next to me. Thought process was something like this: What if I need that guy? Well you can call him on the radio, but there's nothing he's gonna say that you dont already know. What if I can't do this? What if I have to wash out? Well that's OK, but first I gotta get back on the ground before deciding that. Then I leaned on the window, looked at the plane ahead of me, made my turns, and by the time I was on downwind it was starting to pass. After landing I taxied back to where I had dropped off my instructor, but he was nowhere to be seen. He'd said to do 3, so I went back out for 2 more takeoffs and landings without incident. What a way to face your fucking demons.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt's not terribly unusual for student pilots to quit right after solo. Not because it's particularly terrifying, but because they've proven they can do it and that milestone is what was important to them.
- phkahler 5y agoI continued. Next time out was solo from home airport to another 20 miles away. It went pretty well. Then there was some major stress in my personal life, and after that I lost a bit of nerve. Was working back up to solo flight again and then had to hang it up for a while. Hoping to get back to it one day. There's something about it that's different than any other thing in life.
- travisgriggs 5y agoI got my private pilot 14 months ago. I hope you get a chance to return and complete the journey. It’s worth it.
- phkahler 5y ago
- sandworm101 5y ago>> no one outside the airplane is going to bring the airplane safely to its next runway. That is the western pilot culture. Russian pilots have a different approach. Rather than a lone pilot in control of "their" airplane, a Russian air force pilot is flying the people's airplane. In some situations nearly every action, every turn or switch, can be commanded by a ground controller. A western pilot will trust his over instruments over ground control. A Russian pilot will likely obey ground control over his own instruments. Neither culture is better or worse than the other, only different. Go back to the 1950s and 60s and military aircraft, even in the west, were literally controlled by ground control. Autopilots were cued by ground control computers, thereby freeing pilots to manage other systems such as early radars. An aircraft, particularly an interceptor like the FOXBAT, was seen less as an aircraft under control of a pilot than a missile platform, an airborne SAM site. Ground controllers could manage the radars and even fire missiles.
- dotancohen 5y agoDo you have any sources for that? It's fascinating, I've never heard that perspective before. But it does jibe will with the US vs Soviet space programs, in which the Astronaut Office (NASA) demanded that the pilot be able to actually pilot the craft in contrast to the Soviet spacecraft which were autonomous. Interestingly enough, just last week saw the first flight of a completely autonomous manned US spacecraft: The Inspiration-4 flight in a SpaceX Dragon. There was no professional astronaut pilot onboard, and the four tourist crewmembers had less than a year of training, I think closer to six months.
- sandworm101 5y agoDirect citations, not with me. But I know of at least one major crash caused by this difference in flying cultures. Two planes were on a collision course. The Russian plane listened to ATC, the western plane ignored ATC and instead listened to their collision avoidance instruments (TCAS). Both ended up taking the same avoidance action (as opposed to one going up and the other down) resulting in collision. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_%C3%9Cberlingen_mid-air_collision#TCAS_and_conflicting_orders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_%C3%9Cberlingen_mid-air_c... "The manual described TCAS as "a backup to the ATC system", which could be wrongly interpreted to mean that ATC instructions have higher priority.[5]: 80 [BFU 13] This ambiguity was replicated in the Tu-154 Flight Operations Manual, which contained contradictory sections. On the one hand, chapter 8.18.3.4 emphasised the role of ATC and describes TCAS as an "additional aid",[5]: 53 [BFU 14] while chapter 8.18.3.2 forbade manoeuvers contrary to TCAS.[5]: 103 The BFU recommended that this ambiguity should be resolved in favor of obeying TCAS advisories even when these were in conflict with ATC instructions."
- simonswords82 5y agoYep, aviate, navigate, communicate - in that order.