3 ms·
But if we remove the theology—views about the nature of God, the creation of the universe, and the like—from the day-to-day practice of religious faith, the ani
by Animats 5y ago
But if we remove the theology—views about the nature of God, the creation of the universe, and the like—from the day-to-day practice of religious faith, the animosity in the debate evaporates.
Of course, then it's no longer a religion. It's a social organization.
It seems to be quite possible to overdose on religion. Some religions do that as policy, as a form of brainwashing. The religions with mandatory prayer several times a day work like that. It's really hard to break people free of that brainwashing if they grew up with it. It's not the theology, it's the repetition. Both haredi Judaism and Islam use that approach to induce some degree of fanaticism. The Catholic Church, in previous centuries, was into that sort of thing, but has lightened up a bit.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoMy experience with Buddhism was that theology was very much not the point, but most people still consider it a religion.
- asdff 5y agoBuddhism can in practice be very religious. The life of your typical buddhist monk really doesn't look that different from the life of your typical christian monk, they just utter different prayers while lighting their candles. The Pali Cannon reads a lot like the new testament too
- spicymaki 5y agoI was a practicing Mahayana Buddhist for many years and I can assure you it is a religion. There is an entire pantheon with Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, ancestors are worshipped. There are temples, rituals, idols, altars, prostration, chanting, incense lighting, religious texts, etc. There is an afterlife via rebirth which you are trying to end via merit making (virtuous acts). Most of the religious practices are there. There is even a religious rite similar to the Christian sacrament of confirmation called taking the precepts where you make certain religious commitments, and you are given a Buddhist name after time of religious study. I think it is pure fantasy that people believe Buddhism is not a religion. I think some people want to convert Buddhism into just philosophy because they want to take out the interesting content and drop the baggage (rituals, worship, etc.). Many are leaving Christianity with the hope of finding a spiritual community without all of the negatives of religion. However without the baggage there is no meaning or purpose and people will fill in the blanks with their own culture and religious upbringing.
- cratermoon 5y ago> it's no longer a religion. It's a social organization. That's a rather narrow definition of religion. Perhaps consider one suggested by Paul Tillich in his writings - "faith is not simply the will to believe" - such as The Dynamics of Faith and The Courage to Be - concern with the nature of ultimate reality - doubt is included in every act of faith - courage to make a personal commitment - the will to believe does not create faith - venture: acting when the outcomes are beyond one's own control
- dredmorbius 5y agoDifferent forms of human organisation seem to find their own specialised elements of esssential waste. Essential in the sense that they're necessary for function, waste in that in a strictly rational sense, they're inefficient. Market-based corporations develop planned obsolescence, redundant marketing, feature churn, and style-over-function in mass market appeal. Government bureaux tend to be adversarially structured against political adversaries, internal, partisan, or foreign. Militaries are structured around political, cultural, and martial requirements, as well as an environment of infrequent but extreme risks. "Hurry up and wait", inefficiencies of troops and materiel, and actions which lack apparent consistency from the front-line tactical to the general headquarters strategic level are common. And in religious organisations, you'll find that a number of social functions (see Max Weber on the sociology of religion) such as trust, group-cohesion, longevity, tradition, uniformity of faith and doctrine, etc., create structures and behaviours which don't make sense on first blush, but which do seem to have at least some logic when viewed at scale in both space, time, and population. I find it interesting that it is religions and academic institutions which seem to be among the most long-lived. They greatly outlive virtually all commercial enterprises, and all but the most durable governments. Arguably cities might be another contender.