3 ms·
Reads like: "These people are too stupid to use my internet." Your faith that your poor old relative can come to no good end if he's allowed access to public f
by h2odragon 5y ago
Reads like: "These people are too stupid to use my internet."
Your faith that your poor old relative can come to no good end if he's allowed access to public forums is not an argument I can respect. You could be wrong, and where's your right to keep him from going to hell in his own way? Find him better forums that can help, if you so fear the people he may meet.
"On the Internet, no one knows you're a dog" is still one of the greatest reasons to have an Internet. People with differences can more easily ignore those and collaborate ont heir shared interests, and thats a good thing. Whether we approve of those interests or not is a separate issue.
How do you identify this class of people who aren't fit to be heard? Who gets to decide?
- jungturk 5y agoI can understand that takeaway, but I think he's pointing out something more interesting: There are side effects of the way that we conduct society today that can become huge problems when mixed with social media. Solutions span the range from "prevent the mixing", "adjust society's side effects", to "eliminate social media" (with a reasonable or pragmatic option likely somewhere in-between).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- esyir 5y agoI'm pretty openly in support of gatekeeping. I'd have set the bar a bit earlier, but most people are going to set it in a way to include themselves anyway. However, I think gatekeeping is overly maligned right now. A fully open community is exceedingly unlikely survive going viral. Influx of new users at that scale is likely to outnumber existing users at a much larger scale, resulting in replacement, or at least dilution of the source community.
- golemotron 5y agoTrue. It is telling that he identifies his old relative as someone who would be prone to problematic beliefs about an outgroup. It is lost on him that he is adopting similar beliefs about the outgroup his relative represents. It's a stunning lack of self-awareness.