2 ms·
OK, so that's a good explanation as far as the head counting is concerned. But the extra head has a body. Well 3/4 of a body: the Siamese twin has his own torso
by kazinator 5y ago
OK, so that's a good explanation as far as the head counting is concerned. But the extra head has a body. Well 3/4 of a body: the Siamese twin has his own torso, two arms and one leg. Where is that from?
the 3/4 of a body come from to produce the Siamese twin, who has his own torso, two arms and a leg?
This is kind of like, imagine we have a slide rule with two moving parts:
. . , | | | |
| | | | ; ' '
Here I have six vertical features, placed side by side. Now I slide the rows relative to each other:
. . , | | | |
| | | | ; ' '
wee, now I have seven vertical features.
Let's do it with circles:
https://i.imgur.com/9tuNkbT.png https://i.imgur.com/9tuNkbT.png
Just by chopping and sliding, I turned 10 circles into 11. Apparently. But of course, the 11 objects are not really circles; they don't have the full area.
- kazinator 5y agoHere it is with stick figures. https://i.imgur.com/MbrCthN.png https://i.imgur.com/MbrCthN.png We can do the "head examination" here too, but it's actually irrelevant and "wrong-headed" because that situation is a consequence of what I did, rather than the basis. We can ask, where did the extra head come from for the new stick figure on the far right? And here it is actually plain to see: the previous four figures have different slices of their head removed, which precisely add up to a complete head. There is nothing special about the head; the same holds for all the entire figure. Sam Loyd's bicycle wheel drawing conceals the principle by having the boy figures in different positions, and around a wheel rather than a linear slider.