3 ms·
0. Eliminate police unions, period. A group entrusted with upholding the law through sanctioned violence must not be allowed to have any other command structure
by mindslight 5y ago
0. Eliminate police unions, period. A group entrusted with upholding the law through sanctioned violence must not be allowed to have any other command structure. When a factory's union goes against management, the factory shuts down. When a police union goes against their management, we get the police riots of 2020.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> When a police union goes against their management, we get the police riots of 2020. Or we get that time that the Baltimore (I'm like 90% sure it was Baltimore) PD stopped enforcing everything that wasn't an obvious danger to the public. The only two groups who didn't like that were the government who was missing out on revenue and upper middle class types who were really pissed off that people were riding unregistered dirt bikes on the street. It was kind of a nice break for the common man.
- mindslight 5y agoSure, a parallel command structure may make a good decision while the nominal command structure is corrupt. But I'd still say it's better to focus on the problem with the nominal command structure (eg why is the bike registration bureaucracy so overbearing) than to hope that the parallel structure will choose public benevolence when protesting their own issue. Furthermore I'd say that more often than not, a parallel structure for the police is going to choose actions that are not in the public interest. Hence how you're remembering this singular example of some temporary mostly harmless anarchy.
- pessimizer 5y agoPolice unions are some of the most representative unions we have. The police are small-minded sadistic racists, and that is reflected in their union. The way to improve the police is to improve the set of laws they are called on to enforce, and to strengthen the limitations on their behavior (and to dress them like mailmen again rather than soldiers.) If the police aren't called on to act unethically/cruelly as a duty, better people will become police, and the ones who thrived on being bullies will quit.
- mindslight 5y agoDifferent avenues of reform are not mutually exclusive. Yes, better people and removing the mandate to act like Rambo would make the police better. But simultaneously the bullies occupy the positions of power within the union, and they aren't going to leave quietly. We've seen plenty examples of good cops who have turned in their coworkers (ie actually doing their job) and have been consequently forced out despite union "protection". The problem is that a police union can define policy that is extralegal, but carries more weight than what is legal, since they're the ones tasked with actually enforcing the laws. You haven't really addressed that. I know unions are in a sad state in this country and I agree that isn't a good thing. But police having a monopoly on violence makes their union into a completely different beast.