3 ms·
> it’s not engineering milestone that makes a POC a product My first reaction to this statement was, "no that's wrong." But then on reflection, I think that i
by Verdex 5y ago
> it’s not engineering milestone that makes a POC a product
My first reaction to this statement was, "no that's wrong." But then on reflection, I think that it might be accurate. HOWEVER,
> Besides, the only difference between the two is whether it has customers
This is wrong.
The difference between a proof of concept and a product, is that a product is assumed to be reasonably safe. A proof of concept can be barely held together by string and tape. Because it's just trying to gage the reactions of the stakeholders. Or even exploring the feasibility of the idea itself.
A product had better get the edge cases cleaned up. If you write an email client that sends the user's password to some random URL, then that's okay because it's just a proof of concept. Nobody should be using it yet. On the other hand, if Microsoft's Outlook sends your password off to some random URL, then that's a serious problem. Because Outlook is a product.
Proof of concept has a "use at your own risk" or "for demos only" attached to it.
Product has a moral and ethical obligation of the manufacturer attached to it. It had better be reasonably safe to use for the intended (or reasonably accidental) usages.
- sweetheart 5y agoI see what you're saying, I just don't view it like that. There isn't any definitive way to say something is or isn't a product versus a proof of concept, my criterion included (it having customers). Sure, maybe there are some really polished proofs of concept, and maybe there are absolutely horrendous products. Using your example of Outlook sending passwords, that doesn't suddenly mean it isn't a product and was reverted back to merely a POC. It's just a shit product. Fortunately, it doesn't really matter. I just think folks shouldn't be so quick to shoot down one's accomplishments. Imagine seeing someone pursue their dreams and work on stuff they love, and the audiences reaction is "well, it's actually not a _real_ product." That's just lame.
- theobr 5y agoWould love for some of these commenters to tell my customers to go back to Zoom because it's a "real product" lol Really appreciate the support man. I've built enough "real product" to be confident that this method of building is just as real as the rest.