4 ms·
I think the cleanest law here is to change the law to clarify that non-public information gained by public servants and representatives that can have an affect
by pclmulqdq 5y ago
I think the cleanest law here is to change the law to clarify that non-public information gained by public servants and representatives that can have an affect on a stock's price should be treated as "material non-public information." Then the SEC can do their jobs like they do with other insider traders.
Remember that ONLY elected congresspeople are exempt from rules like that. Other public servants are not. This is one of the biggest signals that the US is an oligarchy and not a democracy.
- giantg2 5y agoI'd go a step further and restrict them to index funds. Even just holding a stock could affect their judgement. So they might not trade it to their benefit, but they might make the wrong policy decision for the country.
- pledess 5y agoThe NPR article says "pushing a bill that would require members to divest individual stocks within six months of taking office and limit their investments to mutual funds." This new distinction (investment opportunities for members of Congress are different than investment opportunities for other Americans) creates a new conflict of interest for lawmakers who then must choose whether to invest in mutual funds instead of non-stock-related asset classes. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/16/democratic-plan-would-close-tax-break-on-exchange-traded-funds.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/16/democratic-plan-would-close-... suggests that the Senate may soon consider a less favorable tax treatment of the use of in-kind redemptions by mutual funds. If senators perceive that their own stock investments will be limited to mutual funds or other funds (i.e., not individual stocks), then they may have a greater incentive to vote against this tax-law change, regardless of whether the change is good public policy.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoYou can do a lot more with index funds than you think. For example, you can buy sector index funds to get exposure to more limited stocks, and going further, you can actually construct linear combinations of index funds to gain exposure to single stocks. Maybe if you restrict them to only S&P 500 index funds then you could stop them from trading like this. I would rather they just be barred from trading on insider information regardless of the trading vehicle.
- SkyMarshal 5y ago> I'd go a step further and restrict them to index funds. Or alternatively, restrict them to govt debt only. Make sure they have direct skin-in-the-game for the debt they're responsible for managing.
- giantg2 5y agoHahaha that's awesome. I bet they would abuse that too though
- SkyMarshal 5y agoTrue, there would have to be some requirement that they keep, say, at least 30% of their net worth invested in govt debt for 10yrs after they leave office. To better incentivize them to manage it for the long term rather than short term.
- pirate787 5y ago> "This is one of the biggest signals that the US is an oligarchy and not a democracy." The constitutional doctrine of separation of powers generally limits regulatory law enforcement by the executive against the legislative branch. This is actually a signal of constitutionally limited government-- this is a design feature.
- colpabar 5y agoThis feels like a stretch. I really doubt anyone who designed the constitution intended to give lawmakers the ability to trade on insider information obtained through their position legally.
- refurb 5y agoNo, but they intended to limit the Presidents ability to create new regulations that could put legislators in jail.
- giantg2 5y agoExcept the legislature gave the executive branch the power to create and enforce those regulations. Not to mention the type of abuse the restriction is aimed at preventing would still be allowed to take place against regular citizens (classic examples are ATF definitions changing randomly and even conflicting with statute or other regulations).
- refurb 5y agoYes, it gave the executive branch those powers but exempted itself. And with good reason - can you imagine if a sitting president created a new regulation that conveniently put his congressional opponents in prison?
- giantg2 5y agoDo you have a link to that? Can you imagine a world where the president can do the same to ordinary people? On the whole, regulatory agencies lack the checks and balances that our system is supposedly built on. https://www.heritage.org/courts/report/who-will-regulate-the-regulators-administrative-agencies-the-separation-powers-and https://www.heritage.org/courts/report/who-will-regulate-the...
- s1artibartfast 5y agoInsider information is notoriously difficult to identify and prosecute, so while this is an important aspect, I dont think it is a complete solution. We would have to understand what the SEC baseline is for catching insider trades. The easiest and most robust solution is a blind trust.