6 ms·
It's the most blatant example of insider trading. Company insiders might have inside access to a single company. Lawmakers have access to inside information tha
by giantg2 5y ago
It's the most blatant example of insider trading. Company insiders might have inside access to a single company. Lawmakers have access to inside information that can affect the entire industry or market.
It's a perfect example of how we do have class stratification in society and that rule of law and equality are laughably distant ideas in a sea of hypocrisy.
- seventytwo 5y agoGood point. Maybe all that’s needed is for better prosecution of insider trading for these guys? Of course the problem is the power they have to resist or meddle in any prosecution efforts… that’s always the problem with holding the powerful to account, I guess.
- giantg2 5y agoThe biggest issue in enforcement efforts is not that they can meddle, it's that they are "one of us". They are insiders of the system and other insiders don't want to arrest or prosecute them because there are ulterior motives. One is that if they start arresting and prosecuting insiders for something like this, that may remove the longstanding customs that protect themselves from similar things. There's also the idea of upholding the offices they hold. For example, complaints against judges are so secret that they will not disclose information related to them even if they contain exculpatory information and you subpoena them. Why? Because secrecy is necessary to preserve the public's trust in the system. If anything, that secrecy and reasoning should make any rational person question the integrity of the system. There are also plenty of stories of high profile politicians blatantly ignoring any number of laws and putting people in danger (driving violations are extremely common).
- TomGullen 5y agoI'd be more concerned that if a law maker had a million of Tesla stock and Tesla lobbied them, it would take someone with concrete morals to not factor in their potential gains. Humans are not great at making decisions without considering their own incentives - you can trick yourself and your subconscious can sway you.
- jbverschoor 5y agoMorals, or a different risk/reward ratio
- giantg2 5y agoThe people with the best morals/ethics understand the subconscious part and remove themself from the situation by not holding individual stocks in that capacity. As a society, I would hope we could do a similar thing and legislate it as a requirement.
- caseysoftware 5y agoIt gets even more complicated than that.. When they bought that Tesla stock, was it just because they thought Tesla was a great investment opportunity or was it because they believe in a renewable energy economy? If it was an ideological investment too, then they may make decisions to support the industry (and therefore their investments) naturally without any nudging. The lobbying/campaign contributions are just gravy at that point. I lean towards NPR saying "mutual funds or nothing" but it doesn't address the fact that they could still leak sensitive information and/or help out a family member, friend, etc, etc
- mox1 5y agoOhh, you mean like the current Democratic leader of the House of Representatives? https://finance.yahoo.com/news/nancy-pelosi-buys-tesla-calls-191017279.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/nancy-pelosi-buys-tesla-calls...
- pmcollins 5y agoit’s orders of magnitude worse than mere profiting from inside knowledge. these people make policy for the entire country and they have conflicts of interest.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoI think the cleanest law here is to change the law to clarify that non-public information gained by public servants and representatives that can have an affect on a stock's price should be treated as "material non-public information." Then the SEC can do their jobs like they do with other insider traders. Remember that ONLY elected congresspeople are exempt from rules like that. Other public servants are not. This is one of the biggest signals that the US is an oligarchy and not a democracy.
- giantg2 5y agoI'd go a step further and restrict them to index funds. Even just holding a stock could affect their judgement. So they might not trade it to their benefit, but they might make the wrong policy decision for the country.
- pledess 5y agoThe NPR article says "pushing a bill that would require members to divest individual stocks within six months of taking office and limit their investments to mutual funds." This new distinction (investment opportunities for members of Congress are different than investment opportunities for other Americans) creates a new conflict of interest for lawmakers who then must choose whether to invest in mutual funds instead of non-stock-related asset classes. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/16/democratic-plan-would-close-tax-break-on-exchange-traded-funds.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/16/democratic-plan-would-close-... suggests that the Senate may soon consider a less favorable tax treatment of the use of in-kind redemptions by mutual funds. If senators perceive that their own stock investments will be limited to mutual funds or other funds (i.e., not individual stocks), then they may have a greater incentive to vote against this tax-law change, regardless of whether the change is good public policy.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoYou can do a lot more with index funds than you think. For example, you can buy sector index funds to get exposure to more limited stocks, and going further, you can actually construct linear combinations of index funds to gain exposure to single stocks. Maybe if you restrict them to only S&P 500 index funds then you could stop them from trading like this. I would rather they just be barred from trading on insider information regardless of the trading vehicle.