3 ms·
I think you're conflating ethics/morals with legality. Something that is legal, by definition, is not extralegal. Civil asset forfeiture is legal, and is ther
by kelnos 5y ago
I think you're conflating ethics/morals with legality. Something that is legal, by definition, is not extralegal. Civil asset forfeiture is legal, and is therefore not extralegal.
> We live in a country where the authorities can confiscate cash when they see it without reason and consequence. That, to my eyes, is extralegal.
No, it's not, because it is, unfortunately, legal. "Your eyes" aren't really relevant here; the law is what matters.
> Whether the law gives them this de-facto power is beside the point
No it's not; "legal" and "extralegal" mean specific things. You can't just redefine them to mean whatever you want.
- lolwut09883 5y agoI think you’re conflating the systems outcomes with the systems intents, and you think if we made the system with good intent, the outcomes cannot be questioned. But in reality, the system is poorly constructed, and often co-opted by bad actors in law enforcement. All apples in that barrel are bad, when they’re strong arming money from people, wouldn’t you agree? If this was a story about China, I bet your little angry dick would be shuddering with rage, wouldn’t it?