3 ms·
It's very possible that there just isn't much demand. This is likely for a number of reasons: - x86 just has better support for the stuff Azure's "enterprise"
by smoldesu 5y ago
It's very possible that there just isn't much demand. This is likely for a number of reasons:
- x86 just has better support for the stuff Azure's "enterprise" customers want
- ARM servers are often more expensive to spin up than an equivalently specced x86 option
- PRISM compliance is easier on x86 (half-joking, half not)
I like ARM, and I owned a Rev1 Raspberry Pi when those were cool. But even now, ARM still has yet to make a strong case for existing on the server. And that's before we even discuss architectures like RISC-V that are out on the horizon, much better suited for servers than ARM. I'm not planning on an "ARM revolution" taking place in the next decade unless x86 is critically compromised in some way.
- donavanm 5y agoCan you clarify point two? I was under the impression that the wide consensus was for Graviton instances to have significantly better price performance for most workloads. And the current state of arm support is surprisingly good for opensource or linux based server software.
- acdha 5y ago> But even now, ARM still has yet to make a strong case for existing on the server This is several years out of date: AWS Graviton instances are usually a fairly substantial savings over similar Intel, with AMD in between, and Cloudflare has been reporting rather good numbers as well: https://blog.cloudflare.com/designing-edge-servers-with-arm-cpus/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/designing-edge-servers-with-arm-... The main reason I suspect Azure doesn't have it is both Windows' legacy x86 hyper-focus (the days where NT ran on half a dozen platforms never really panned out) and a smaller number of managed services. AWS has very popular services like RDS, ElastiCache, ElasticSearch/OpenSearch, etc. where you can simply check a box and wait a couple minutes to see savings, not to mention things like Lambda being only slightly more work for many users, and that's a great way to get volume usage even if the average enterprise IT department is scared to go near it for VMs.
- fomine3 5y agoIt's not obvious whether AWS internal operation cost of Graviton instance is cheaper than Intel/AMD instance. I believe it's cheaper in AWS scale, but I also think they tactically reduce profit margin for Graviton instances, to negotiate Intel/AMD to cut down price.
- acdha 5y agoThat's certainly possible but wouldn't we see some indication in comparison with Azure, GCP, Oracle, etc. who would have no incentive to do so?
- Kipters 5y ago>Windows' legacy x86 hyper-focus There have been multiple consumer ARM Windows products on the market for the last 9 years, I'd say Windows (client, at least) on ARM64 is as solid as its x64 counterpart
- acdha 5y agoI’m aware, but everyone I know who had one of those ended up complaining about software compatibility issues. In the context of Azure, I’d imagine a lot of their customers would be especially risk averse in this regard.
- Kipters 5y agoMost of the time they're complaining about not being able to use x86 (in Windows RT's case) or x64 (until recently) pre-existing applications, and there's no native ARM/ARM64 version of said app. In the context of Azure, if someone wants to deploy on an ARM instance, I'd expect them to be able to build a native ARM64 version of whatever they're building.
- acdha 5y ago> In the context of Azure, if someone wants to deploy on an ARM instance, I'd expect them to be able to build a native ARM64 version of whatever they're building. Have you really had the experience that a large organization has the ability to recompile everything they run? Most will have a lot of code which is provided as binaries by a vendor, and their in-house code almost certainly has dependencies and optimizations which will need to be dealt with & revalidated. No, none of that is unsolvable but it means adoption is much harder than, say, changing an RDS instance type and you'd be taking on all of the support rather than the cloud provider's much larger team. That's what I referred to in my original comment — in my experience, the average Azure user works at a Windows-heavy enterprise IT shop where those issues would be common. That doesn't mean that I don't expect ARM servers to happen there — Microsoft announced it was coming years ago, after all — but that it's going to be slow since the upfront investment will likely have slower adoption.
- bserge 5y agoIs it cheaper for the end user? If not, what's the point of using ARM over x86 besides ideological reasons?
- acdha 5y agoYes, that's why they offer them and have done numerous comparisons showing this as a cost-savings move?
- bserge 5y agoI don't know that's why I'm asking. Every comparison I've seen was cost saving for the datacenter.
- acdha 5y agoDo you mean end user as someone other than the buyer of a cloud service? That’s the context I was writing in - I’ve generally found things like https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2020/10/achieve-up-to-52-percent-better-price-performance-with-amazon-rds-using-new-graviton2-instances/ https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2020/10/achieve-u... to be accurate as long as you’re not radically switching instance types.