3 ms·
Why is that a negative? If a book has interesting, engaging content why is it bad that it has 200 pages instead of 20?
by paxys 5y ago
Why is that a negative? If a book has interesting, engaging content why is it bad that it has 200 pages instead of 20?
- Jtsummers 5y agoBooks like this, IMO, are generally better when split into 2 pieces: 1. A "core" that describes the motivation for the ideas and then the ideas (as in, what makes a checklist, how comprehensive do they need to be, basic ideas on how to store and maintain them). 2. An expanded form, providing more detail on the motivation (issues that could have been mitigated if not eliminated with checklists, areas where checklists have succeeded, more specific practices around checklists that worked for some people, for the reader's consideration). This lets you skip the fluff if you've already been persuaded by going with (1), or if you need to be persuaded or want ideas on how to persuade others going with (2). A lot of useful material ends up suffering from self-obfuscation by only providing or too strongly pushing (2) and not (1). Since there is the New Yorker article, in this case both (1) and (2) exist (after a fashion, it's been a few years since I read that article so I'm not sure anymore what's in it but it is much briefer than the book).
- fredoliveira 5y agoBecause with less padding, people could spend the other 180 pages reading about 9 other ideas. Naturally, I know that's not so simple, but it is one of the key issues I have with books that say the same thing over and over again — lack of respect for the reader.
- colechristensen 5y agoBecause usually it doesn’t. It usually boring redundant content where you have to dig for the point. The same is true for many articles: what I needed was a picture and a caption, what I got was 2000 words which didn’t add much at all. Good writing of this kind makes its point right away and invites you to read more to expand on the point instead of holding the main idea hostage for most of the piece. Another failure of the attention economy.
- larrywright 5y agoIf he had only written the book, I likely wouldn't complain. But the fact that he accomplished the goal - convincing me that checklists were awesome - in a much shorter article, tells me that the rest of the book was unnecessary.