2 ms·
I don't think that's what was intended. I think the idea is "Set your admissions bar to the minimum level, then admit however many students meet it." Or, if yo
by jfengel 5y ago
I don't think that's what was intended. I think the idea is "Set your admissions bar to the minimum level, then admit however many students meet it."
Or, if you have only 800 possible seats, "Set your admissions bar, then pick 800 of them randomly". The more you "raise" the bar, the more your definition of "raise" matters. It will tend to select people who can afford (in time, money, connections, etc) to meet your specific criteria. And you run the risk of accidentally setting your criteria to be "more like me" (in looks, patterns of thought, etc.)
If you assume that your school can benefit anybody smart enough to meet your criteria, why not take as many as you can? And why not aim to get more people who couldn't focus on your criteria? Randomness won't seek them out, but it at least won't prefer a 1500 SAT by a student who does nothing but take SAT tests to a 1460 SAT by a student who has to work two part time jobs.