2 ms·
This confusion comes from people trying to fit Facebook/Google etc. (I'll just say Facebook from now on) into "old world" concepts. There seem to be two differe
by globular-toast 5y ago
This confusion comes from people trying to fit Facebook/Google etc. (I'll just say Facebook from now on) into "old world" concepts. There seem to be two different views of what Facebook is: some see it as a public square, others see it as a publication. But these are both wrong.
Facebook clearly isn't a public square. It's a platform with a dictator/censor/moderator who controls what is and isn't allowed on the platform. It also seems to be much more susceptible to groupthink, misinformation and extreme viewpoints than a real public square.
But Facebook isn't a publication either. When arguing against free speech on Facebook, some people compare it to newspapers and you'll hear arguments like "the New York Times isn't obliged to publish your article". But that's not what's happening here. Facebook operates more of a blacklist than a whitelist. Nobody thinks of the NYT as explicitly rejecting all but a select few people's writings, but they do think of Facebook as explicitly allowing whatever thing currently offends them.
So what is it? What should it be? These are questions we have to answer for ourselves. Applying rules from constitutions written 400 years ago might not be wise. But moving public discourse on to privately owned platforms is probably not wise either. I think the only thing that's clear right now is something is wrong.