2 ms·
> Some corners of the community tried (unfortunately successfully to some degree) to paint TPMs/Trusted Computing/SecureBoot as generally evil technologies that
by mschuster91 5y ago
> Some corners of the community tried (unfortunately successfully to some degree) to paint TPMs/Trusted Computing/SecureBoot as generally evil technologies that stop us from using our systems the way we want. That idea is rubbish though, I think.
It's not as rubbish as the author wants to think. Just look at the current state of Android SafetyNet attestation - a myriad of apps refuse to run entirely (banking apps, games) or with reduced quality (Netflix) on unlocked bootloader / rooted systems. There are workarounds but these are a) a constant cat-and-mouse game and b) the only known workaround against online SafetyNet attestation (pretending that the device does not have a TrustZone element, forcing SafetyNet to Basic attestation) is bound to fail as soon as Google is reasonably certain that there is no hardware floating around that has the latest Android but no TrustZone element.
Additionally, look at what happened to Microsoft's ARM adventures. Locked down to the point of being utterly useless, on top of MS not providing a Rosetta equivalent.
The problem is that here the interests of hackers (who either want as-open-as-reasonably-possible devices or, like the author, as-secure-as-possible devices) and big corporate interests (who want to keep license holders happy like Netflix, want a way to reduce successful "my device got pwned, someone stole my money, refund me!!!" claims like banks or fight against cheaters) collide in a position that's hard to make something decent out of.
- aseipp 5y agoThe modern Windows ARM laptops all(?) use standard x86 Secure Boot/UEFI rules, as far as I know. You can install Linux on them pretty easily; I know at least Fedora/Anaconda supports ARM64 pretty well. The bigger problems come after that but are more of the same stuff, i.e. lack of drivers for peripherals, you're dealing with Qualcomm, etc.
- no_time 5y agoI would LOVE tpms and every other hardware security feature if the had an user override that allows me (and only me) to control what the device does. Basically the opposite of the current and forseeable landscape.