12 ms·
I believe the first pre-condition is that people actually need to care about their opinion being reflective of the truth. This is not a natural thing to care ab
by atoav 5y ago
I believe the first pre-condition is that people actually need to care about their opinion being reflective of the truth. This is not a natural thing to care about, because it doesn't give you social capital directly (quite the contrary: having an opinion that is reflective of the truth can hurt your social standing in many, many places).
So before we ask how people could maybe we should ask how we get them to actually want this?
- munificent 5y agoWhile believing the truth does not always provide social capital, it very often provides material capital, which is why humans over eons have evolved mental faculties that make us want to know true things. These faculties aren't perfect, obviously, we're just primates, but they work better than we give ourselves credit for. If I'm trying to decide which lake has the most delicious fish, the actual true answer is very important when it comes to deciding where to drop my line, regardless of whether others think I'm wrong. Reeling in dinner—confirmation from material reality—is its own reward.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y ago> So before we ask how people could maybe we should ask how we get them to actually want this? I've never understood that sort of mentality* in the first place, and I'd be very surprised if I was the only one. So I'm guessing this isn't an "everyone" problem, but more of a "most people" problem. So maybe the question to ask would be "What makes turns people into truth-seekers vs. agreement-seekers?" * Edit to clarify: the mentality of seeking "social truth" rather than objective truth, and ignoring or denying evidence in favour of group policy.