4 ms·
Penny a share transfer tax for all trades. What's a "share"? Equities are one of many financial markets, but not the only one and not necessarily the most imp
by jrockway 15y ago
Penny a share transfer tax for all trades.
What's a "share"? Equities are one of many financial markets, but not the only one and not necessarily the most important. People trade bonds, treasuries, foreign currencies, commodities, interest rates and various derivatives on top of these securities: equity options, FX options, interest rate swap options, FX forwards, etc., etc. How would you tax options contracts? Tax when exercised? But you wanted it to be a trade tax, so should it be a dollar per standard contract?
Your model is too simple and does not reflect the reality of the financial markets. And anyway, if there's one thing banks are great about, it's passing on the fees to their clients. A one cent per-share transfer tax doesn't mean Wall Street is out of business. It means you won't have enough money in your 401k to retire.
Still on board? Ok, now if a company releases forecasts, they must release the model they used to generate the forecast. Yes, the code. Doesn't matter how simple or complex. Bullshit forecasts will be self-evident. Data for better ones will be more available.
Why do companies have to have "a model"? You wouldn't ask da Vinci for the "code" behind the Mona Lisa; why should accounting be automatically less creative than painting? All regulations will do is force companies to get money from source other than a public offering -- private investment, bond issues, etc.
Anyway, I'm not saying that taxing trades is a bad idea, I'm saying that your idea doesn't make much sense in the real world. Communism is a good idea. On paper.
- Cushman 15y agoI'm with you aside from this: "why should accounting be automatically less creative than painting?" I'm sure you don't mean what it looks like, but I can't imagine what that could mean.
- jrockway 15y agoWhy can't your "gut" be involved in forecasting the success of your company? People often come up with the right answer without knowing how; making them write down every assumption they made while coming up with an answer would make coming up with an answer impossible. The real world is not 9th grade math.
- Cushman 15y agoPeople often come up with the wrong answer without knowing how, too. They just forget about those times. It's been well documented— your perception of the "real world" is heavily distorted. That's why we have math— to figure out the right answer despite human biases.
- T_S_ 15y agoMy point was about forward looking statements and inducing companies to reveal their rational processes. So by all means, use your gut. Then show your work. People can then bet on your gut. Or somebody else's work.
- qntm 15y agoJust forcing a company to say "We expect X amount of growth in the next financial quarter, and the reason we expect this amount of growth is - even though we are an international financial corporation - guesswork and gut feeling, rather than any kind of formal model" would be a step forward. You have two companies. Both predict X growth. One provides a full model which backs up their prediction. The other flat-out states that they made the number up. Which would you pick? It doesn't actually matter - the point is that their operations are more transparent and your choice is more informed.
- damoncali 15y agoI think he means that if you force every company into the same financial mold, you're not going to get anything interesting in the public markets. Anyone outside the box will not play in the public arena because the rules will be so restrictive as to be unworkable. Most people think of accounting as being like math. It's more like writing.
- Volpe 15y agoCreative accounting? How can something that is supposed to report 'reality' be 'creative'. It's analytical, and highly objective... where is the creativity?
- damoncali 15y agoIt's analytical, and highly objective Is it? The deeper you look, the more arbitrary it gets, in my view.
- Volpe 15y agoCould you expand on that? From my point of view, it's money in vs money out... I'm not sure how "creative" you can get before you are "lying".
- damoncali 15y agoIt's been a while sine I felt comfortable discussing the details of accounting, but sometimes the need to classify things gets in the way of the truth. Do you capitalize a cost or expense it? Often you can argeue both sides of the coin, but ultimately, you're forced to choose. The quantitative nature of accounting masks a nuanced and imprecise language meant to help communicate the overall financial story of a company. It's not like physics where there is a right and wrong answer. You could use "creative" methods of describing and classifying transactions that aid in telling an accurate story (as defined by who?). You can also twist the truth. But there is no set of rules you can universally follow that will result in The Answer.
- adamtmca 15y agoUpvoted. While financial accounting (statements for shareholders, taxes etc) is governed by GAAP and meant to be as standardized across orgs as possible, managerial accounting (internal statements for the purpose of decision making) require a lot more decision making about how you measure things in the interest of providing the most accurate financial picture of the decision at hand. I am very rusty so anyone who has some real experience in accounting, please correct me. That said, consider a simple example: a manufacturer which sells two types of windows and creates the glass which is used in them. Line A of windows is selling at lower than expected prices and in financial accounting terms it is loosing money. On the other hand, line B is selling well and appears profitable. With this in mind, the company kills line A expecting to increase their profitability by the amount the line was previously loosing. Unfortunately, the subsequent decrease in the amount of glass the organization is producing reduces the scale of their glass making operation and drives up their per-pane cost. At these higher input costs, line B is no longer profitable at it's current selling price and the company looses even more money than they would have had they continued to run the "unprofitable" line A. Of course, any competent management team would be able to forecast this scenario and devise a host of other solutions (sell glass to a competitor, for example). But the question here is: how should they present this reality in financial accounting? Decrease the recorded cost of glass used in line A? Add some sort of subsidy from the profits of line A? All of a sudden it becomes extremely "creative".
- jerf 15y ago"And anyway, if there's one thing banks are great about, it's passing on the fees to their clients. A one cent per-share transfer tax doesn't mean Wall Street is out of business. It means you won't have enough money in your 401k to retire." While I agree with the rest of your criticisms, this is off base. You have to consider the second-order effects; banks will not simply continue to trade at the exact same volume as before whatever (presumably somehow fixed-up) tax is imposed, then pass the costs on to hapless consumers who have no choice but to just fork over the cash. They will have to trade less. Which is the point; however good or bad it may be, at least the core idea is making some account of second-order effects. When you tax a thing, you get less of it. (My specific opinion is that it isn't necessarily a net gain as written, it is after all just an HN comment, but that the general idea of carefully re-inserting some friction back into the market as a damping factor may be a useful line of inquiry. But it's not going to be easy.)
- T_S_ 15y agoMy example tax is only a conversation starter. You would be right to say that the reality is a little more complex. But not much. I worked in the bond, fx, and commodities end of Wall Street for nearly 20 years and an average guy from my old department would know how to set, implement and administer such a tax for each product. It's not that hard. In fact a similar system existed for regulatory capital for a very long time. The Communism comparison is really a red herring. The principles of the price system, the central feature of a free market, are under constant assault from informational asymmetries and externalities of all kinds. Before our era of jargon, they were simply called fraud and rumor mongering. HFT is 21st century micro-rumor mongering. To protect the functioning of markets these are appropriate objects of regulation--even for a free marketeer like me. I merely suggest we modify the the regulation of an already regulated market. Unfortunately the style of regulation we keep opting for punishes bad behavior of individuals--when it does anything at all--and ignores the systemic causes. This repeatedly plays into the hands of industry interests every time. The public interest requires more information, to reduce the tendency for fraud that our regulators have proven they cannot control.