3 ms·
There's a criminal trial going on in downtown San Jose as we speak, of someone who also applied lessons from elsewhere to a place where they don't fit: Elizabet
by AlbertCory 5y ago
There's a criminal trial going on in downtown San Jose as we speak, of someone who also applied lessons from elsewhere to a place where they don't fit: Elizabeth Holmes & Theranos.
Her responses whenever someone challenged her were similar to most of the commenters here: "first they say it's impossible, then you change the world." She was thinking of computers and her idol, Steve Jobs. She would never talk about blood tests and accuracy, only about how cool it would be to change the world.
Unfortunately, Moore's Law does not apply everywhere. "Hard sciences" are hard. We have it easy in software. Boundless optimism is only appropriate in certain domains, not in all of them. Most of us on Hacker News (not all of us, I'm sure) have spent our lives in the domains where it is.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoBoundless optimism seems inappropriate anywhere outside of religion, but ridiculous mind-blowing optimism, at least, seems to me and many others warranted by recent advances in biotech.
- AlbertCory 5y agoNot for her, though. There was that pesky fact that blood tests already exist, and people were going to compare her results to theirs. And "ridiculous mind-blowing optimism" led to a lot of people losing their money, people who now appear on the government's witness list for her trial. And then we have President Clinton announcing that the success of the Human Genome Project was going to lead to countless breakthroughs in medicine. I've taken a bunch of UCSC Extension classes in bio, so I know it's certainly helped. But it wasn't like Moore's Law kicked in all of a sudden. There's certainly progress, you're right. But doing things on a gigantic scale takes gigantic amounts of time.