3 ms·
So I think where this idea runs into problems is assuming that people actually want or need a Dyson swarm. The sun puts out 3.846×10^26W. Let's assume a Dyson
by rsynnott 5y ago
So I think where this idea runs into problems is assuming that people actually want or need a Dyson swarm.
The sun puts out 3.846×10^26W. Let's assume a Dyson swarm manages 10% capture efficiency, and a future population of 100 billion. That would result in every person having access to 384TW, or about 25 times Earth's total power consumption.
Clearly, that's far too much power for any reasonable use-case, so at that point you're talking about either a far higher population (quadrillions) or far smaller collection area. Earth's population seems to be destined to cap out at about 9bn, and the trend away from population growth is most pronounced in highly developed energy-hungry countries. So _we're_ probably never going to need a Dyson swarm, anyway...
- cletus 5y agoFirst, you'd be surprised how many people we can support. Like we could likely support more than a trillion people on Earth. The population of a full Dyson Swarm around our Sun likely caps out in the quadrillions, possibly quintillions. Second, it's entirely valid to ask the question of whether we'd ever reach such populations. This is of course unknown. As a solution to the Fermi Paradox, the idea of reaching a steady state (or even shrinking to a fragment) seems unsatisfying as a 100% outcome. Once again, it only takes 1 to keep growing and become detectable. A lot of things are likely to change in the next millenium, for example: 1. I expect we will live much, much longer than we do now; 2. Automation will increase to the point where labour is highly unlikely to be the limiting factor in any kind of industrial output. That leaves resources and energy as the limiting factors. Well, resources are just a proxy for energy. There are several rocky bodies in the Solar System that could, given enough energy, provide unimaginable amounts of raw materials; 3. Despite the wealth of developed nations, we are still living in an era of relative resource scarcity. Individuals in developed nations are certainly generally more prosperous than those in developing nations but it's expensive to raise children in developed nations the way most parents want to raise them: paying for education, housing, etc. I'm not comfortable making the prediction than the modern trend of having relatively few children per individual in the developed world will continue into an era of longer lives, far more abundance and being freed from the need to work their entire lives to set up those children. Lastly, there are some very obvious applications for huge amounts of energy, for example: 1. Extracting resources; 2. Vast amounts of computing power. What would you do with this? We haven't been good at predicting this other than to say that more bandwidth and more computing power has thus far always found applications that people want. One obvious one is I suspect we'll have VR worlds that people will basically live in on a scale we can't possibly yet imagine; 4. Interstellar travel; and, of course 5. Cryptocurrency mining. :)
- pleb_nz 5y ago'Clearly, that's far too much power for any reasonable use-case'. Where have I heard that or something similar before? ;-)
- raducu 5y agoWe won't reach 11bn people because of urbanisation and economic reasons. There could be quintilions of amish people farming in a Dyson Swarm :)
- rsynnott 5y agoAh, the Ringworld model. Realistically, it's not just urbanisation. Back when people regularly had 15 children, that meant that people were (a) basically continuously pregnant for 15 years and (b) spent around 30 years of their life bringing up children. Even without economic constraints I doubt it would be a very common approach; if nothing else you don't see that many billionaires with 15 children.