4 ms·
This is yet another NFT thing. The NFT fad seems to be reaching peak Ponzi. Axie seems to be the worst. This has become a huge fad in the Philippines. It's so
by Animats 5y ago
This is yet another NFT thing.
The NFT fad seems to be reaching peak Ponzi.
Axie seems to be the worst. This has become a huge fad in the Philippines. It's sort of like Pokemon, except that it costs about $1000 to get into the game. For a few months, poor people were buying into this and making enough money to quit their job. Then the supply of suckers ran out. The token is down 85% from peak.
There are now metaverse NFTs with "presales". The promoters don't bother creating a virtual world; they just sell "land" in one that doesn't exist yet, with vague promises of a future implementation. That's almost certainly an illegal public offering of an security under US law. (Look up "Howey test").
Even Decentraland, the NFT-based virtual world, only has 275 people logged in right now.[1] (Compared to about 40,000 for Second Life, over a million for Roblox...) People who bought "land" in Decentraland for a "virtual store" are not getting much traffic.
The SEC shut down most of the ICO scammers. NFTs were invented as an end run around securities law. Since each one is different, they're not a commodity, so the CFTC lacks jurisdiction. If they represent a real world thing, they're a collectable, not a security. But most of the newer NFTs represent nothing.
Getting away from uppity domain registrars would help. Originally, you owned a domain. Now, registrars take the position that you just rent it from them. But NFTs are not the answer. Too many scams and scammers.
[1] https://catalyst-monitor.vercel.app/ https://catalyst-monitor.vercel.app/
- jekkos 5y agoI smell a false analogy fallacy. Axie NFTs are fad so just avoid all NFTs at all cost? I think that the concept of an NFT is quite a useful one, and you should maybe not consider the value of it as a first thing. Domain names were also speculated upon in the early days. Remember people buying up 3 or 4 letter dommain just to sell them for more money? It's just a change in the trustmodel behind DNS that is really needed here. Instead of trusting a chain of certificate authorities you can trust a blockchain's consensus mechanism instead.
- southerntofu 5y ago> I think that the concept of an NFT is quite a useful one How so? Can you name a few useful applications? From my understanding NFTs are only as useful as "property titles", which means they have exactly one and only one application: speculation, which in my book is an absolute anti-feature. > Instead of trusting a chain of certificate authorities you can trust a blockchain's consensus mechanism instead. I think you meant registries, not CAs? How is "blockchain consensus" better, given all the blockchain failures we've witnessed so far with BTC/ETH and all the related hacks, monopolistic overreach from state-sponsored hardware vendors, and lack of consensus on the software leading to hard forks? Don't you think hard-wiring monetary incentives to something as basic as a naming scheme can only lead to bad outcomes (as ICANN gTLD programme has demonstrated)? What's your take on the GNU Name System? Concerns about it being a GNU project aside ("it'll be ready when GNU/Hurd is ready"), what do you make of the features and threat model? Personal opinion: on paper, i find it's the least-worst naming system i've ever read about.
- knownjorbist 5y ago> NFTs were invented as an end run around securities law. Uh, no, NFTs are a standard as defined here: https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/standards/tokens/erc-721/ https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/standards/tokens/erc...
- duskwuff 5y ago> Originally, you owned a domain. Now, registrars take the position that you just rent it from them. I've never seen any mainstream registrar take that position. If you were going to argue that a domain name "belongs" to anyone other than the registrant, it'd be to the registry itself, not to a registrar.
- Animats 5y agoICANN: "Remember, paying to register a domain name is not the same as "buying" it outright or permanently. You do now "own" a domain name. What you are doing is more like leasing the domain name from the registry operator that the domain name is associated with. Registration periods can vary depending on the registry operator. You cannot buy a domain name forever. However, you can continually renew its registration (before the registration period expires) to maintain control over it. While the term "buying a domain name" is also commonly used in relation to purchasing an existing domain name registered to someone else, the purchaser is not buying the domain name, but just acquiring the rights to register it to themselves and continue to manage and re-register it in the future." [1] https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/faqs-84-2012-02-25-en#10 https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/faqs-84-2012-02-25-en#...