5 ms·
> Now that the workings have been revealed, An0m is a trick that could surely never be repeated in the world of organised crime. The revelations will push crimi
by bitwize 5y ago
> Now that the workings have been revealed, An0m is a trick that could surely never be repeated in the world of organised crime. The revelations will push criminals away from technology, even if it makes their work more laborious and slow-moving.
I can imagine future organized crime information flows more closely resembling what was depicted in John Wick: a lot of secretaries and file clerks pushing paper around, using old mechanical adding machines and typewriters; if they do touch a computer, it's a VIC-20 or similarly ancient, internet-incapable device.
- eptcyka 5y agoIts harder to erase paper trails, so I think the future of crime is using open source or in-house comms tools.
- bitwize 5y agoFire, judiciously applied, can erase paper trails rather efficiently.
- eptcyka 5y agoAnd evidence of burning possibly indicting evidence is all the more indicting.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThis is what document-retention-and-disposal policies are for. In major business districts throughout the Western world, document disposal companies will drive their collection truck to a given business address and shred the collected paper right there in the street as it's loaded into the truck. You can see them everywhere. You can hear them long before you see them.
- dankent 5y agoThat sounds like it would be a big win for law enforcement. If you can force your opponent to avoid some modern ways to communicate, you can put a big dent in their efficiency. It's possible that paranoia might lead to criminals avoiding even technology that they could be using safely, further slowing them down. An old fashioned system also seems like it would require more people, opening up more opportunities for human intelligence operations targeting the network.
- yholio 5y agoOr they could learn to use Signal. Properly installed (F-Droid) on off-the-shelf phones with fresh prepaid sims and OS updates disabled, it can be considered secure software against all but the most sophisticated adversaries. Then, simply verify the handshake key for your contacts, and you can be sure there is no man in the middle attack. Rotate phone+sim every 2 months, while keeping the same "outside" number, say, a landline you control. There are attacks against this too, but they are very noisy (modify all Signal binaries delivered to a certain area) or typically exceed the technical capabilities of run-of-the-mill agencies (exploit an OS zero day).
- monocasa 5y agoThe easier way to attack this is by instituting a know your customer law for phone systems including prepaid SIMs, combined with accomplice charges for anyone who's SIM is used in connection with criminal acts.
- VLM 5y agoPeople are too free with their phones. Just walk into a bar and say you're too drunk to drive and could the bartender call my wife to pick me up? Not knowing its actually picking up $60M worth of coke instead of picking up me. Or pull off to the side of the road, walk in well dressed, wave a dead iphone in front of them, ask the receptionist "hey my car broke down and my battery is dead, could you call this number and tell them my car broke down?" Or bonus points if the cops arrive because you're blocking traffic, ask the cop to call on their phone. (edited I got the best idea that most anyone would fall for: Slip a kid $20 to ask an adult to call his mommie because he got lost...)
- monocasa 5y agoThat's a function of there not being penalties. You'd see that change if the laws changed.
- 5y ago
- hkt 5y agoNot unlike the FSB: https://www.rt.com/news/typewriters-russia-order-surveillance-975/ https://www.rt.com/news/typewriters-russia-order-surveillanc...
- dredmorbius 5y agoCuriously, a similar organisation would bug same. https://web.archive.org/web/20210730214414/https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-crazy-story-of-how-soviet-russia-bugged-an-american-embassys-typewriters https://web.archive.org/web/20210730214414/https://spectrum.... https://archive.is/T16Fj https://archive.is/T16Fj (GDPR-noncompliant cookie policy at origin.)
- sumnole 5y agoBesides criminals, even legitimate businesses might start to prefer offline methods. With the decline of privacy comes corporate espionage and that's no good for business.
- kube-system 5y agoLegitimate businesses can much more easily avoid being scammed by vendors because their legitimate businesses are protected by the legal system. They also can openly discuss their experiences with vendors, because they're not hiding from anyone.
- dredmorbius 5y agoHow's that working out for victims of ransomware attacks or nation-state corporate espionage?
- kube-system 5y agoI've never heard of a business being scammed by a vendor through ransomware. When businesses choose vendors, they do it with legal contracts enforceable in their jurisdictions.
- dredmorbius 5y agoVendor-based scams are not the entirety of the threat model.
- kube-system 5y agoVendor-based scams are what this thread and this article is about. The root quoted that An0m was a 'trick' that couldn't be repeated again. My point is that legitimate businesses would have never had to worry about such tricks, being scammed by a vendor like this is a problem unique to illegal businesses.