2 ms·
This designer doesn't understand A/B testing. In Ye Olden World of Direct Mail, everyone worked to beat the control. The control, your most successful mailing
by jdietrich 15y ago
This designer doesn't understand A/B testing.
In Ye Olden World of Direct Mail, everyone worked to beat the control. The control, your most successful mailing piece to date, was the benchmark against which everything was measured. You could modify the control, you could take a completely novel approach, but your work only counted for anything if it beat the control. Clients learned to ignore what they thought about a piece and care only about the results.
What the industry learned was that the only sane way to develop a brand new mailing piece was to imitate established controls. Books like Who's Mailing What and Major Mailers provided an index of successful mailings. Copywriters and designers came to understand the Darwinian nature of mailing and gave up on trying to predict what works. They learned that artistry was at best useless, at worst harmful. Their intuitions were completely wrong - the best-performing mailings were almost universally ugly, stupid and reliant on cheap tricks.
Outside of DM, designers almost never think in this manner. Throughout their education, they are taught to produce work that is aesthetically pleasing to the design world, with perhaps some concessions to accessibility. Aesthetics don't pay the bills.
The purpose of A/B testing is to measure the effects of a decision on the bottom line, but also to act as a driver for decisionmaking. A good DM designer has no hesitation in making a mailing piece look like a payslip or a bill, because he knows that such pieces work. His favourite font is Courier, his favourite colour is fluorescent yellow, his favourite adjectives are "splashy", "bold" and "eye-grabbing". He is blind to aesthetics and seeks only to drive the recipient to the next stage - to open the envelope, to read the headline, to the body, to the insert, to the coupon.
If you're looking to build a brand based on aesthetics, a designer is probably the right choice. If you just want to sell some product, 99% of them are a liability.