4 ms·
One big thing I often see missing in these comparisons of renting versus owning a home is the difference of the housing stock. Sure, I could rent an apartment l
by vel0city 5y ago
One big thing I often see missing in these comparisons of renting versus owning a home is the difference of the housing stock. Sure, I could rent an apartment less than my mortgage + insurance + taxes + maintenance savings, but then I'm most likely living in much less square footage, I probably don't have a private garage, I don't have private outdoor spaces, and I get much less say over the features of the space. My mortgage + escrow amount is a roughly $200 more per month than the last apartment I rented at, but with that I gained over twice the square footage, a two car garage, a pool, and a good bit of private yard. I can run cables in my wall for whatever I want, I can put amateur radio antennas throughout my attic and in my yard, I can install an electric vehicle charger in my garage, I can mount speakers and WiFi AP's on my ceiling, I can do practically whatever with my home without having to get approval from people. For a few hundred dollars a month more, I get significantly more. The apartment and my home are pretty much the same market, they're about 2mi away from each other.
The other aspect is home ownership helps hedge against housing inflation. That rent I paid a couple years ago at the apartment is now more than my mortgage + escrow. True, you still feel the effects of housing inflation through higher taxes and insurance premiums, but even MB's numbers show that to only be 30% of the overall costs of the house. You're going to feel the effects of housing inflation much more being a renter signing new leases every year rather than having a significant chunk of your costs completely fixed (P&I), and maintenance costs when truly budgeted right can be somewhat fixed.
Other than that I really do agree with MB in this. It always amazes me how people don't quite get the idea that your home price going up doesn't really mean great things for you unless you're planning on trading down. A house is worth what a house is worth, you're going to have a hard time really realizing those gains unless you plan on living under a bridge with your pile of money.
Finally, if all you're wanting to do is maximize returns on every dollar that passes through your hands, owning a home isn't necessarily the best choice. The best choice is to rent the cheapest, crappiest apartment with absolutely no amenities in the crappiest part of town and invest everything. But then you're choosing a vastly different lifestyle, so its really a question of what you value in life. Personally, I enjoy floating in my pool after a stressful day of work and find a lot of value in that but maybe you find looking at your Coinbase wallet more relaxing.