5 ms·
I think (1) is probably the main questionable assumption, to be honest. Let's take as given that travel faster than light via some form of cheating isn't possib
by rsynnott 5y ago
I think (1) is probably the main questionable assumption, to be honest. Let's take as given that travel faster than light via some form of cheating isn't possible. Under that assumption, for mass interstellar travel in reasonable time, you would require the ability to produce vast amounts of cheap energy (either via fusion on the starship, or antimatter produced with cheap energy at home and used on the starship, or by some other means).
And at that point, where is the incentive to colonize other star systems? You're still probably not going to be able to move a meaningful part of your population, and if you can produce energy that cheaply you can sustain a large population in comfort at home.
It's not inconceivable that there are advanced aliens all over the place, but that interstellar travel is basically limited to probes for pragmatic reasons.
I think when the Fermi Paradox was brought in, there was still some lingering Malthusian idea that geometric population expansion was inevitable. We now know it very much isn't, at least for us. That changes things.
- kindle-dev 5y agoEven without FTL travel, just having constant acceleration at 1g is enough to travel the width of the galaxy in 12 years ship-time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_travel_using_constant_acceleration#:~:text=At%20a%20constant%20acceleration%20of,would%20take%20about%2024%20years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_travel_using_constant_ac....
- rsynnott 5y agoThat is a _huge_ 'just', tho. That's a lot of energy.
- htrp 5y agoWelcome to the delta V problem....
- jandrese 5y agoTry plugging 12 years of 1G acceleration into the Rocket Equation. If reactionless drives remain science fiction this mode of travel is flat impossible. There literally isn't enough mass in the solar system.
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoWe always assume that civilizations expand into space without consideration for benefit, but I don't think that will be the case, honestly. Should we want a colony on another planet? In another star system? Absolutely. It doesn't take much expansion for us to achieve the goal of having a 'redundant backup' for humanity. Beyond that, there has to be some sort of economic incentive to drive it. Given there is little chance we can economically trade between planets, much less between star systems, I don't think that incentive is there.
- netjiro 5y agoOne benefit is reduced risk of extinction by the various nasty ways the grand cosmos might annihilate a local-only civilisation. Let's consider extinction mitigation as a luxury? I posit that sooner or later, as technology improves, the relative cost of such projects will go down to a point where some group of people think it is a good idea.
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoAgain, you don't have to expand to more than a couple of self sustaining planets in a couple of solar systems to establish a reasonable redundant backup for mankind. I don't think new discoveries suddenly change the physics of escaping gravity wells. I question whether interplanetary trade will ever move beyond intellectual property. Basically, colonization will have to be altruistically funded without any expectation of economic return. We've proven we have limited capacity for that.
- Loughla 5y ago>We've proven we have limited capacity for that. Currently. In a system where resources are allocated not to cover the needs of all, but instead to ensure that the victor gets their spoils, this is true. But IF a civilization makes it to a point where self-sustaining planet settlement is even a real possibility, I think you just have to assume they are post-scarcity and post-currency. Economic return isn't really a thing, if everyone can get what they want whenever they want it. Therefore, any species with a natural propensity to exploration and curiosity as an individual is going to necessarily seek out new places as a whole. The individual will drive the societal, I guess is what I mean there. Because I want to see something new, and there is no scarcity of resources, society as a whole gets to see something new. >I question whether interplanetary trade will ever move beyond intellectual property. Honestly, I don't think so. Because, again, I'm of the firm belief that once a society is able to establish off-world colonies successfully, economics stops meaning anything at all, really.
- deepsun 5y ago> if you can produce energy that cheaply you can sustain a large population in comfort at home Don't see the reasoning here. For example, we currently can feed the whole Earth population "cheaply". But the wars didn't end. Same with cheap energy. E.g. we can try to install vast amounts of mirrors to direct Sun's light towards an accelerating ship. But that won't bring us here more comfort.
- Gravityloss 5y agoWell, maybe "constant speed" is a bad wording. An example: We have 1000 stars within the 30 light year radius neighborhood. Traveling at Voyager 1 speed, it takes half a million years to do a 30 light year trip. [1] Given another half a million years for bootstrapping at the destination for ten more probes, we can send ten more probes, 1 million years from the launch of the first one. At two million years we get 100 probes. How many probes do we get in a 11 million years? 10^11 probes. We have 10^11 stars in the galaxy. Dinosaurs roamed the earth aleady 200 million years ago, and died in the mass extinction 65 million years ago. 20 to 5 million years ago was the Miocene, when life was pretty close to modern already. [2] It's really the nature of exponential growth that makes things seem instantaneous compared to celestial phenomena or evolution. Colonizing the galaxy, even with abysmally slow speeds, is possible, because of the magic of exponentials. (Certainly this has a lot of assumption, like that you can bootstrap, or that the probe survives the trip. Anyway, optimal probes would be a lot faster and bigger, and there would be more of them. This was just to tie in with something concrete that we know we can do, as Voyager 1 really is out there traveling at 15 km/s, as are Voyager 2, Pioneers and New Horizons probes.) 1: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=+30+light+years+%2F+voyager+1+velocity+ https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=+30+light+years+%2F+vo... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miocene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miocene
- PeterisP 5y agoThe big issue here is different understanding of "reasonable time". The galaxy is very large, and the time spans involved are very large, but they are not in the same ballpark of "large", the time gaps involved are so much larger. If one civilization gets their evolution of intelligent life just 1% quicker than us, that's a head start of 50 million years. On that scale, "reasonable speed" required to fill the galaxy (to use round numbers, 10000 "hops" of 10 ly each for 100000ly distance across the whole galaxy) means something like a planet launching a single colony ship to a nearby star once in 5000 years (and the new colony populating the planet and launching another ship in 5000 years, which seems quite reasonable). You don't need FTL, you don't need fast ships, you don't need many ships, just one generation ship in a few millenia moving at 0.01c or even less is amply sufficient to colonize all of the galaxy many times over in that time range. And if someone was 2% or 3% faster than us, then they'd have even more excessive time to swarm the galaxy even if they're doing it at snail's speed. So to explain the fact that the aliens aren't swarming everywhere because they can't afford it means accepting that either they launching a single generation-ship every 5000 years is a huge expenditure (which IMHO it wouldn't be even with our current economy size, definitely not an issue with the tech of 2100 or 2200 assuming at least some growth because at that point a Musk-type figure with a wish to "make humanity interstellar" would be able to afford it from private funds) or that we're the first (only?) life in galaxy or that all the aliens before us didn't try to expand, like, at all - because getting just one single rich eccentric every 5000 years (like a bunch of billionaires here are) would be sufficient to make the galaxy swarm with juuust a bit higher tech level than ours now.
- betwixthewires 5y agoWell, you're assuming that technological advancement is linear and one way. We simply have not been technologically advanced in any notable way that we know of to be the least bit certain that this is true. A lot can happen within 5000 years.
- raducu 5y agoThe problem with generation ships is we assume we can just "zip" all knowledge and technology and ship it via a generation ship and "unzip"/bootstrap at destination. I'm sure we are absolutely not capable to do that now. Maybe with AI. But we haven't done that with our Moon and that's not even a few lightseconds away.
- betwixthewires 5y ago> And at that point, where is the incentive to colonize other star systems? Just to put this out there, unless every advanced civilization becomes a hive mind with one unified will, some individual or splinter group or just hodgepodge of determined individuals would probably do it even if there were no incentive, and that's not to point out that incentives are somewhat subjective and differ between individuals and groups. If there are enough individuals on a civilization and the capability exists, some crazy person will do it.